Link


Social

Embed


Download

Download
Download Transcript

[00:00:03]

HELLO ALL, THANK YOU FOR JOINING. WELCOME TO THE SEPTEMBER 2026 FINANCE ECONOMIC RESILIENCY COMMITTEE MEETING. UH, WE'LL TRY AND GET THROUGH SOME THINGS TODAY. WE ALSO HAVE A VERY IMPORTANT BUDGET MEETING, UH, LATER THIS EVENING, UM, THAT WILL CLOSE OUT OUR, UH, ANNUAL BUDGET PROCESS. SO, UH, I THINK THAT WILL BE THE KIND OF STAR OF THE DAY. UM, SO MAYBE WE CAN GET THROUGH SOME THINGS HERE TODAY.

UH, PROBABLY WON'T GO TOO LONG, JUST GIVEN THAT, UH, WE HAVE THE LATER, MORE COMPREHENSIVE AND SUBSTANTIAL MEETING TODAY. BUT LET'S GET THROUGH SOME THINGS. I'LL T- TURN IT OVER TO OUR CFO, UH, TO OUR CITY ATTORNEY TO KICK US OFF, AND THEN, UH, I SEE SOME RESIDENTS HERE, UH, SO WE'LL, WE'LL GET TO SOME THINGS THAT PEOPLE ARE HERE IN THE AUDIENCE FOR.

THANK YOU. GOOD MORNING.

TODAY'S MEETING OF THE FINANCE AND ECONOMIC RESILIENCY COMMITTEE HAS BEEN SCHEDULED IN HYBRID FORMAT WITH A QUORUM OF THE COMMITTEE PHYSICALLY PRESENT AND REMAINING MEMBERS, STAFF, AND MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC APPEARING EITHER IN PERSON OR VIRTUALLY VIA ZOOM. IN ORDER TO PARTICIPATE IN TODAY'S MEETING VIRTUALLY, MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC MAY DIAL 1-888-475 OR 499 AND ENTER THE WEBINAR ID, WHICH IS 86360595462# OR LOG IN TO THE ZOOM APP AND ENTER THE WEBINAR ID WHICH AGAIN IS, 86360595462.

ANY INDIVIDUAL WISHING TO SPEAK ON AN ITEM MUST CLICK THE RAISE HAND ICON IF USING THE ZOOM APP, OR DIAL STAR 9 IF YOU ARE PARTICIPATING BY PHONE.

THANK YOU. JUST HAVE A COUPLE OF ANNOUNCEMENTS. UH, OB1 IS

[OB 1. DISCUSS POTENTIAL IMPROVEMENTS TO TROLLEY ADVERTISING REVENUE AND CONSIDER ISSUANCE OF AN RFP FOR ADVERTISING SERVICES.]

WITHDRAWN, MB10 IS DEFERRED,

[NB 10. DISCUSS THE FEASIBILITY OF REPLACING THE PLANNED 5TH STREET PEDESTRIAN BRIDGE WITH AN OVER WATER CONNECTION LINKING THE BAYWALK SOUTH OF 5TH STREET WITH THE BAYWALK NORTH OF 5TH STREET]

AND OB3 HAS A 10 A.M. UH, TIME CERTAIN. AND I BELIEVE, CHAIR, THE FIRST ITEM YOU WANTED TO HAVE WAS MB8, CORRECT? YEP, MB8. I APPRECIATE THAT. I SEE SOME PEOPLE HERE FROM THE NEIGHBORHOOD. LET'S GET THAT OUT OF THE WAY. I THINK THAT SHOULD BE QUICK, AND THEN WE'LL GO TO UH, OB3 AND NB5, UH, THAT'LL BE HEARD TOGETHER.

THANK YOU. UH, LET ME READ

[NB 8. DISCUSS POTENTIAL LOCATIONS FOR ADDITIONAL GOODWILL SOUTH FLORIDA DONATION TRAILERS.]

IN MB8, UH, DISCUSS POTENTIAL LOCATIONS FOR ADDITIONAL GOODWILL SOUTH FLORIDA DONATION TRAILERS, MB8.

AND I BELIEVE THIS IS, UH, COMMISSIONER FERNANDEZ. I'LL TURN IT OVER TO YOU. UH, TREMENDOUS INITIATIVE. I HAD THE HONOR OF, UH, GOING OUT THERE AND SEEING IT IN PERSON, AND I HEAR, UH, IT WAS, UH, TORTY FROM YOUR VISIT. UH, YOU GOT OUT THERE AND, UH, SO, SO I'LL TURN IT OVER TO YOU TO INTRODUCE.

THANK YOU, MR. CHAIRMAN, AND THIS IS AN ITEM THAT I'M SO HAPPY TO BE SPONSORING TOGETHER WITH A NUMBER OF OF OUR COLLEAGUES, UH, COMMISSIONER MATTEO-SALINAS, COMMISSIONER TANYA BHATT, AND FOR THOSE OF US THAT HAVE BEEN OUT TO THE GOODWILL FACILITY, LIKE YOURSELF, MR. CHAIRMAN, HAVE SEEN THE INCREDIBLE, THE INCREDIBLE WORK, UH, THAT THEY DO, NOT ONLY, UH, TRAINING IN INDIVIDUALS WITH INTELLECTUAL D- DISABILITIES, BUT ALSO SUPPORTING OUR LOCAL ECONOMY AND SUPPORTING, UH, PEOPLE OF, OF NEED THROUGHOUT, THROUGHOUT OUR COMMUNITY. AND THIS ITEM SPECIFICALLY RELATES TO IDENTIFYING LOCATION WITHIN OUR MUNICIPAL LOTS WHERE WE COULD HAVE TRAILERS FOR DONATIONS, UH, IN BENEFIT OF GOODWILL AND THEIR, AND THEIR MISSION. AND WE'VE BEEN WORKING, UH, WITH OUR PARKING DEPARTMENT ON IDENTIFYING SOME POTENTIAL LOCATIONS THAT COULD BE CENTRALLY LOCATED IN OUR CITY, AND I THINK IT'S A, IT'S AN EASY WAY. IT'S AN EASY WAY FOR OUR CITY GOVERNMENT TO GIVE BACK IN AN IN-KIND MANNER TO A TREMENDOUS CAUSE THAT'S HELPING A LOT OF PEOPLE IN OUR COMMUNITY. SO, MR. CHAIR, IF YOU ALLOW ME, I'D LIKE TO RECOGNIZE OUR PARKING DIRECTOR, MR. WILLIAM MCDONALD.

OF COURSE. UH, GOOD MORNING, WILL MCDONALD, DIRECTOR OF PARKING. UH, SO WE'VE, UH, WORKING WITH THE COMMISSIONERS, WE'VE IDENTIFIED 2 LOTS. UH, WE LEFT THE VERBIAGE SLIGHTLY VAGUE IN HERE IF THERE'S EVER A NEED TO RELOCATE, UH, WE CAN IDENTIFY THESE. THE TWO LOTS IN QUESTION ARE GOING TO BE P63, UH, MORE WIDELY KNOWN TO THE PUBLIC, UH, THE LOT ON 42ND AND IN BETWEEN PRAIRIE AND ROYAL PALM, AS WELL AS P5, WHICH IS ON THE CORNER OF ALTON AND 4TH STREET. SO THESE ARE TWO LOCATIONS VERY CENTRALIZED WITHIN SOUTH BEACH AS WELL AS, UH, MID BEACH, UH, THAT CAN PROVIDE EASY ACCESS IN AND OUT FOR THE PUBLIC, AND WE THINK THEY'RE GREAT LOCATIONS FOR THE CITY.

AND MR. CHAIRMAN, IF YOU, IF YOU ALLOW ME JUST TO FOLLOW UP, UH, WELL, WE'RE GOING, THIS IS NOT JUST ALLOWING THEM TO HAVE A PERMANENT TRAILER THERE FOR DONATIONS, BUT THEY ALSO, THEY'RE GOING TO BE PAYING FOR THE USE OF THESE SITES.

CORRECT, YES, THERE IS A PAYMENT INVOLVED WITH THIS. UM, SO OBVIOUSLY, YOU KNOW, WE WANT TO TRY TO WALK THAT FINE LINE OF, OF, OF BEING GOOD STEWARDS TO THE COMMUNITY, ENSURING THAT WE CAN GIVE SPACE, UH, WHERE IT BENEFITS BOTH THE COMMUNITY AND THIS GREAT ORGANIZATION, UM, WHILE AT THE MAIN TIME ENSURING THAT WE, UH, UH, UH, FOLLOW SUIT WITH ALL OF OUR BOND REQUIREMENTS.

AND, AND FOR THE UTILITIES, UH, BECAUSE OBVIOUSLY WE KNOW THAT THERE'S ELECTRICITY THAT'S INVOLVED. HOW IS THAT BEING HANDLED? UH, SO WHAT WE'LL DO IS, IS THAT WILL GENERALLY GO THROUGH OUR BUILDING DEPARTMENT FOR ANY PERMITS THAT ARE BEING

[00:05:02]

PULLED, BUT AS THE, AS THE LOT OWNERS, THE PARKING DEPARTMENT, UM, WILL KIND OF POINT THEM IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION AND LEAD THE WAY TO ENSURE THAT THEY FIND THE PROPER HOOKUPS. THIS IS SOMETHING THAT WE DO VERY COMMONLY WITH TECHNOLOGY PARTNERS AND VENDORS THAT ARE INSIDE OUR LOT ANYWAY, SO IT'LL BE A VERY EASY LIFT FOR THE DEPARTMENT.

THANK YOU, MR. CHAIRMAN.

YEP. UH, OUR FORMER MAYOR, UH, MAYOR DAN GELBER, A TREMENDOUS GENTLEMAN, UH, HE WOULD ALWAYS CAUTION ABOUT SPEAKING WHEN YOU'VE ALREADY WON, UH, BUT I WILL TURN IT OVER TO, UH, THE NEIGHBOR THAT HAS, UH, JUST BECAUSE I KNOW THE TREMENDOUS AMOUNT OF WORK AND, EXCUSE THE PUN, GOODWILL THAT GOES INTO THIS.

HAPPY TO SAY THINGS, BUT BY NO MEANS NECESSARY. I THINK YOU'RE GOING TO HAVE A TREMENDOUS AMOUNT OF SUPPORT HERE.

AND NO, THANK YOU FOR HEARING US OUT AND NO COMMENTARY NECESSARY.

THANK YOU FOR WHAT YOU DO FOR THE COMMUNITY. OKAY, THEN, UH, DOES SOMEBODY WANT TO MAKE A MOTION? I THINK, IF I MAY, I THINK HEARING IT WOULD BE TO RETURN TO COMMISSION WITH A FAVORABLE RECOMMENDATION TO DIRECT THE ADMINISTRATION TO NEGOTIATE AND EXECUTE AN AGREEMENT, UH, FOR ADDITIONAL GOODWILL, UH, DONATION, UH, CENTERS AS PRESENTED.

YES.

HAPPY TO MAKE THAT MOTION.

OKAY, AND I'LL SECOND.

OKAY, WE'LL SHOW COMMISSIONER MONICA SALINAS, AND ALL IN FAVOR? AYE.

ALL RIGHT, AND PASSES 3 NOTHING.

THANK YOU, COLLEAGUES.

THANK YOU, COMMISSIONER.

WE'LL CALL- YEP. GO AHEAD.

[OB 3. DISCUSS A PROPOSED NEW AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY AND THE GREATER MIAMI CONVENTION AND VISITORS' BUREAU FOR DESTINATION MANAGEMENT SERVICES]

SORRY. WELL, THE NEXT ITEM WILL BE THE TIME CERTAIN OB3, DISCUSS A PROPOSED NEW AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY AND THE GREATER MIAMI CONVENTION AND VISITORS BUREAU FOR DESTINATION MANAGEMENT SERVICES, OB3.

WHERE'S STEVEN? GOOD MORNING, CHAIR, UH, MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE, UH, COMMISSION. UH, CERTAINLY THIS IS FOR, THIS FIRST ITEM IS FOR THE, UH, GREATER MISSOURI CONVENTION, I MEAN, GREATER, GREATER MIAMI CONVENTION AND VISITORS BUREAU. OOPS. UH, THE NEW AGREEMENT THERE. SO, UH, FOR EVERYONE'S, UH, EDIFICATION, THE CITY HAS PARTNERED WITH THE GMCVB, UH, FOR ALMOST 40, OR OVER 40 YEARS. UM, AND SO THIS IS ALWAYS CONTINUE TO ELEVATE MIAMI BEACH AS A WORLD-CLASS DESTINATION. UH, GMCVB REMAINS THE ONLY REGIONAL DMO, UH, WITH INFRASTRUCTURE, GLOBAL NETWORKS, AND DATA CAPABILITIES TO MARKET GREATER MIAMI, INCLUDING GREATER, UH, MIAMI BEACH AT SCALE. SO THIS AGREEMENT CONTINUES THAT PARTNERSHIP TO DRIVE TOURISM, HOTEL OCCUPANCY, ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT, AND RESORT TAX REVENUE. SO THE CURRENT AGREEMENT, UH, AS AS IT STANDS, THAT FUNDING MODEL IS A FLAT 10% OF, UH, 2% RESORT TAX PLUS A 2 MILLION DOLLAR INCENTIVE. UM, WE BELIEVE THAT IT'S IT'S A BIT OUTDATED AND AND NOT RESPONSIVE TO ALL ECONOMIC, UH, FLUCTUATIONS. UM, AS WE KNOW, TOURISM CAN BE CYCLICAL, AND SO THE NEW PROPOSED CONTRACT, UH, UPDATES WITH THE 5-YEAR TERM, UM, FROM, OF COURSE, THIS YEAR TO 2031, AND THEN IT'S A SLIDING SCALE COMPENSATION MODEL. SO THE IDEA IS THAT FROM 8 TO 15% BASED ON ACTUAL MONTHLY 2% RESORT TAX RECEIPTS. AND SO THAT MEANS THAT THE HIGHER THE PERCENTAGE, THE HIGHER THE, THE INCOME, UM, THE LOWER THE RECEIPTS, THE LOWER THE PERCENTAGE, UM, THAT, THAT, THAT FOLKS WILL RECEIVE.

THERE'S A MONTHLY PERFORMANCE TRACKING, SO PAYMENTS ARE AUTOMATICALLY ADJUSTED EACH MONTH, UH, BASED ON VERIFIED TAX COLLECTIONS AND THE REDUCED, UH, MAXIMUM INCENTIVE, WHICH, UM, BELIEVE THE, UM, OUR, OUR FRIENDS AT THE GMCBB ARE CERTAINLY AMENABLE TO, UM, THE ANNUAL INCENTIVE REDUCED FROM 2 MILLION TO 1 MILLION, AS WE'VE GIVEN CONSIDERATION, UH, FROM THE COMMISSION, UH, DURING THIS BUDGET SEASON AND MAKING SURE THAT WE'RE TIGHTENING, TIGHTENING BELTS ACROSS THE BOARD, UM, FROM ALL PARTNERS. AND SO REDUCING THE ANNUAL INCENTIVE FROM 2 MILLION TO 1 MILLION, UM, ALSO, ALSO HELPS IN, IN, IN THAT REGARD. UM, SO THOSE ARE THE, THE MAIN, THE MAIN POINTS, UM, REALLY IN THE, IN THE NEW, THE NEW AGREEMENT, AND CERTAINLY OPEN TO, TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS FROM, FROM THE COMMITTEE.

WE APPRECIATE THAT. ANYBODY UP HERE? IN TERMS OF THE SODEXO AGREEMENT, UH, DO WE WANT TO HEAR THESE TOGETHER, UH, MR. CFO, OR? I THINK IT'S DIFFERENT VENDORS, SO THEY'RE THE SAME IMPLEMENTING DEPARTMENT, DIFFERENT VENDORS, SO I THINK WE DO ONE AT A TIME.

OKAY.

I'LL MOVE THIS ONE.

OKAY.

HAPPY TO SECOND.

I JUST HAVE A QUESTION, IF I MAY, MR. CHAIRMAN.

OF COURSE.

AND I MIGHT BE OPENING A CAN OF WORMS THAT I DO NOT INTEND TO OPEN BECAUSE I, I REALLY LIKE THE GMCVB A LOT. BUT THE GMCVB IS AN ENTITY THAT, THAT IS THE RECIPIENT OF PUBLIC FUNDS. UH, AND SO, AND SO I, I WILL TELL YOU, UM, DURING THE WHOLE FIFA E- EVENTS, I REALLY DID NOT LIKE WHAT HAPPENED WITH THE USE OF GMCVB RESOURCES TO ISSUE A NUMBER OF TICKETS TO AN ELECTED OFFICIAL FOR POLITICAL PURPOSES. THAT I, I DID NOT LIKE. WE ARE ALL CONTRIBUTING TO THE GMCVB, AND I EXPECT THE GMCVB, UH, TO MAINTAIN A GOOD, STRONG RELATIONSHIP WITH THE CITY. UM, AND WE'VE BEEN VERY SUPPORTIVE

[00:10:01]

OF EACH OTHER, BUT IF MOVING FORWARD, I REALLY, I, I DON'T LIKE TO SEE THOSE HEADLINES BECAUSE THEN IT PUTS A QUESTION ON US. OUR CONSTITUENTS ASK US, OUR TAXPAYERS ASK US, WELL, WHY ARE, WHY ARE OUR DOLLARS BEING USED TO SUBSIDIZE THAT? AND SO I JUST, YOU KNOW, WANT TO PUT THAT OUT THERE. I, I, I DON'T LIKE THOSE HEADLINES. I DON'T LIKE SEEING THAT, AND I JUST, MOVING FORWARD, IF YOU COULD ALL JUST BE MINDFUL OF THAT. IT'S AN INCREDIBLE PARTNERSHIP. IT'S A GREAT PARTNERSHIP. SO MUCH PROGRESS HAS BEEN DONE TO- TOGETHER, UM, BUT I WOULD JUST ASK YOU TO BE MINDFUL OF THAT.

IF I MAY, IT SOUNDS LIKE THE MOTION WAS PROBABLY MADE TO RETURN TO COMMISSION WITH A FAVORABLE RECOMMENDATION TO APPROVE THE NEW DESTINATION MANAGEMENT AGREEMENT WITH THE GMCVB AS PRESENTED.

UM, WHO WILL BE MAKING THAT MOTION? I'M SORRY, I MISSED THAT.

COMMISSIONER DOMINGUEZ.

COMMISSIONER DOMINGUEZ MADE THE, AND SECOND? BY... ALL IN FAVOR? AYE.

MM. MOTION PASSES, THANK YOU.

AND FOR THIS SODEXO ITEM, IS THERE ANYBODY FROM THE MAYOR'S OFFICE THAT'S HERE OR WANTED TO CHIME IN? I KNOW THEY'D WORK CLOSELY WITH THIS. DOES NOT APPEAR.

DO YOU KNOW WHERE THAT, UH, KIND OF COORDINATION LIES? ARE YOU. YES.

ABLE TO SPEAK ON BEHALF OF THAT? AND WE DO HAVE REPRESENTATIVE FROM SODEXO. I BELIEVE THEY HAVE HAD CONVERSATIONS WITH THE MAYOR'S OFFICE.

I THINK THAT THAT'S WHY THE THERE WAS THE RELEASE OF THE REFERRAL. I THINK THE REFERRAL WAS HELD UP, UH, IT WAS RELEASED, SO I THINK THAT MUST HAVE BEEN RESOLVED. BUT I'LL I'LL CALL THE ITEM SO WE CAN DISCUSS IT.

OKAY.

[NB 5. DISCUSS AN AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY AND SERVICE AMERICA CORPORATION D/B/A SODEXO LIVE! (“SODEXO”) FOR FOOD AND BEVERAGE MANAGEMENT SERVICES AT THE MIAMI BEACH CONVENTION CENTER AND CLUBHOUSE BUILDINGS.]

MB5, DISCUSS AN AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY AND SERVICE AMERICA CORPORATION, DBA SODEX- SODEXO LIVE OR SODEXO, FOR FOOD AND BEVERAGE MANAGEMENT SERVICES AT THE MIAMI BEACH CONVENTION CENTER AND CLUBHOUSE BUILDINGS. MB5.

ALL RIGHT, SO, UH, SAME SO FOR SODEXO, AGAIN, THAT'S A CONSIDERATION OF THE NEW FIVE-YEAR AGREEMENT WITH SODEXO LIVE, AGAIN, THE FOOD AND BEVERAGE, UM, MANAGEMENT SERVICES AT THE MIAMI BEACH CONVENTION CENTER, WHICH, WHICH HAS CERTAINLY, UM, BEEN A, BEEN A BOOM FOR, FOR OUR CONVENTION CENTER AND THE, THE JOB THAT SODEXO HAS DONE THIS DURING THIS TIME. UM, THE CURRENT AGREEMENT EXPIRES, SO WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT WE'RE MAINTAINING CON- UH, CONTINUITY ACROSS, UH, MAKING SURE THAT WE'RE AVOIDING TRANSITION COSTS, STAFF TURNOVER, RETRAINING, ALL OF THE THINGS THAT WOULD COME ALONG, UM, WITH, WITH THE TRANSITION OF OUR FOOD AND BEVERAGE OPERATOR THERE.

UM, SO SOME KEY POINTS TO JUST POINT OUT WITH THE, WITH THE PROPOSED TERMS, UM, THAT ARE A LITTLE BIT DIFFERENT. SODEXO ACTUALLY COMMITS A LITTLE BIT OVER 3 MILLION, SO 3,005,000 INSTEAD OF THE NUMBER THAT YOU SEE OF THE 2, THE 2.8. UM, SO THAT'S 3,000,000, UH, 5,000 TOWARDS FOOD SERVICE ENHANCEMENTS AND COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT AT THE NBCC AND THE CLUBHOUSE BUILDINGS. UM, AGAIN, THE FINANCIAL STRUCTURE, WE WERE ABLE TO WORK WITH SODEXO TO MAINTAIN THEIR MANAGEMENT FEE OF 4% OF GROSS RECEIPTS, BUT OUR SHARE OF THE NET OPERATING PROFITS WILL NOW INCREASE FROM 83% TO 88%. UM, AND THEN THE THERE, OF COURSE, THE 5-YEAR TERM.

UH, ONE OF THE THINGS IN THE PUBLIC BENEFITS AREA THAT I JUST WANT TO POINT OUT, UM, AS WELL, UH, THERE'S A CONTRIBUTION OF 100,000 THAT WAS SET HERE TO BE ANNUAL, UM, TO BE DONE ONE TIME, FIRST TIME ANNUALLY. UM, NOW THAT AMOUNT IS GOING TO BE 50,000 EVERY YEAR OVER THE COURSE OF THEIR CONTRACT. SO THAT'S, THAT'S A, THAT'S AN, UH, A PLUS THERE. AND SO ALSO JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE IT'S, AND YOU MENTIONED, OF COURSE, UH, THE CONVERSATIONS WITH THE MAYOR'S OFFICE, BUT HOSTING F- UH, QUALIFIED 501C3 AND CHARITABLE EVENTS AT COST. SO THE, THE, THE PREMIUM THAT'S BEEN PLACED ON THIS, SO THE HOSTING THOSE EVENTS AT COST, UM, WAIVING PER GUEST FEES FOR MIAMI BEACH RESIDENTS USING A KOSHER CATERER OF THEIR CHOICE, SUBJECT TO NBCC POLICIES, UM, ALLOWING CHARITABLE, UH, CLIENTS TO BRING OUTSIDE SNACKS AND DONATED FOODS WITH LIABILITY WAIVER COMPLIANCE AND CITY REQUIREMENTS, UH, AS WELL AS PROVIDING 20% DISCOUNT ON HOSPITALITY SERVICES FOR MIAMI BEACH RESIDENTS. UM, FUND DEVELOPMENT OF A KOSHER KITCHEN AND A TASTING ROOM AT THE NBCC. SO I JUST WANTED TO MAKE SURE I POINTED OUT THOSE SPECIFIC, UH, POINTS, BECAUSE I KNOW THOSE WERE THINGS THAT CAME UP AS AS POINTS OF OF CONCERN AND SO FORTH. AND SO WITH THAT, I'LL CERTAINLY ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS FROM THE FROM THE COMMITTEE.

JOE. I FIGURED YOU DIDN'T JUST MOVE FOR A MORE COMFORTABLE SEAT.

GOOD MORNING, UH, JOSEPH SANTORINO, INSPECTOR GENERAL.

I, I DON'T HAVE A COMMENT REALLY DIRECTED TO WH- WHETHER THE, UM, THE, THE AGREEMENT SHOULD BE EXTENDED, ONLY THOUGH TO, TO COMMENT THAT WE HAVE AN ONGOING AUDIT ON, ON SODEXO, AND IT'S BEEN GOING ON FOR SOME TIME, AND, AND THERE ARE SOME ISSUES THAT WE'VE FOUND WITH IT. I, I, THE, THE, THE ADMINISTRATION IS AWARE OF THEM. UH, I THINK, UH, UH, THE, UH, UH, ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT, UH, IS AWARE. I'VE SPOKEN TO MR. GREEN ABOUT IT. YOU KNOW, I, BEFORE ANY FINAL DECISION IS MADE AS TO THE, THE, THE TERMS OF THE CONTRACT, THERE'S DEFINITELY GOING TO BE SOME, AND AGAIN, WE'RE WORKING ON IT. THE, IT

[00:15:01]

DEPENDS ON OUR TIMING, DEPENDS ON THE, THE LEVEL OF COOPERATION WE GET FROM, FROM THE CONTRACTOR TO PROVIDE US WITH THE DOCUMENTATION WE NEED, BUT THERE WILL DEF- DEFINITELY BE, UM, SOME RECOMMENDATIONS IN TERMS OF THE CONTRACT ITSELF AND WHETHER IT SHOULD BE ADJUSTED TO PROTECT THE CITY'S INTERESTS. SO I WANT TO BRING THAT TO THE ATTENTION, UH, OF THE, OF THE COMMITTEE, AND I WOULD JUST CERTAINLY, I THINK NO FINAL DECISION SHOULD BE MADE IN THIS UNTIL WE HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO REVIEW THAT INFORMATION.

AND JOE, WHAT DO YOU EXPECT THE GENERAL TIMING OF THAT TO BE? SHOULD WE... MAYBE I'LL LOOK FOR, TO YOU FOR YOUR GUIDANCE. SHOULD WE KEEP THIS HERE IN COMMITTEE? CAN WE MOVE THIS ON TO THE FULL COMMISSION, UH, WITH FINAL APPROVAL KIND OF CONTINGENT ON HEARING FROM YOU? WELL, EITHER WAY IS, IS OKAY. I TH- I, I, AS I SAID, I DON'T THINK IT'S GOING TO AFFECT THE QUESTION OF CONTINUING THE CONTRACT. I DO THINK THAT THERE ARE SOME TERMS THAT COULD VERY WELL BE AFFECTED, AND THE ADMINISTRATION MAY WANT TO CONSIDER IN NEGOTIATING WITH THE, WITH THE CONTRACTOR ON THE, THE NEW CONTRACT.

AND, UH, I, I WON'T SAY TOO MUCH ABOUT IT, BUT I THINK THE, THE, THE, THE SUBCONTRACTING THAT GOES ON THERE AND THE EFFECT THAT COULD HAVE ON CITY REVENUES IS SOMETHING WE'RE LOOKING AT.

AND I KNOW YOU'LL, YOU'LL PROBABLY BE HESITANT TO COMMENT BEFORE WE HAVE A FULL PICTURE HERE, BUT ARE THESE MORE ADMINISTRATIVE TYPE THINGS AND NOTHING NEFARIOUS THAT SHOULD HANG OVER OUR HEAD? I'M NOT SUGGESTING ANYTHING NEFARIOUS.

YEP.

I MEAN, YOU KNOW, IT'S A MATTER OF INTERPRETATION, AND THERE MAY BE SOME, SOME PROVISIONS IN THE CONTRACT THAT ARE NOT AS CLEAR AS THEY SHOULD BE, AND SO THEY'RE BEING INTERPRETED BY THE, THE CONTRACTOR IN A CERTAIN WAY, AND PERHAPS THE CITY MIGHT WANT TO TIGHTEN THOSE UP.

GOT IT, BUT NOTHING THAT WOULD PREVENT US.

I'M NOT SUGGESTING ANY, ANYTHING NEFARIOUS.

OKAY, OKAY. AND AS FAR AS I KNOW, IT'S SOLELY BEEN IN THE HANDS OF CITY STAFF NEGOTIATING THE TERMS AND THINGS LIKE THAT, SO YOUR TEAM WILL WORK WITH, UH, JOE'S TEAM.

ABSOLUTELY.

UH, IN THE EVENT THAT SOME OF THESE TERMS NEED TO BE FIRMED UP. SO I THINK WITH THAT, AND PUT YOUR HAND UP IF I'VE MISINTERPRETED, BUT IF THERE, IF IT'S THE WILL OF THIS COMMISSION, WE CAN MOVE FORWARD, UH, TO PUT THIS IN THE HANDS OF THE FULL COMMISSION, UH, WHILE INCORPORATING SOME OF THE FEEDBACK, WITH STAFF INCORPORATING SOME OF THE FEEDBACK, UH, BEFORE FINAL TERMS ARE AGREED UPON.

DOES THAT SOUND FAIR? YEAH.

COMMISSIONER.

YES, THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR.

JOE, COULD YOU, I'M SORRY, COMMISSIONER MAGAZINE ASKED WHEN YOU WOULD EXPECT TO THE TIMELINE TO BE JUST A ROUGH, I MEAN, ARE WE TALKING 6 MONTHS, 9 MONTHS, 2 MONTHS? IT IT'S NOT GOING TO BE 9 MONTHS, NO. IN FACT, I THINK THE THE I WOULD SAY WITHIN A COUPLE OF MONTHS WE SHOULD HAVE THE UH THE THE DRAFT OUT, WITH WHICH CASE THE THE ADMINISTRATION WILL HAVE ALL THE INFORMATION THAT THEY REALLY NEED AND CAN PROCEED, I THINK, TO ACT ON IT AT THAT POINT.

OKAY.

IF I CAN, CHAIR, I THINK THAT, YEAH, I THINK THAT WE COULD INCORPORATE THE ANY OIG RECOMMENDATIONS, UH, INTO THAT. SO IF YOU WANT, I CAN TRY TO WORK ON A, A MOTION. OKAY. I, I THINK BECAUSE ALSO THIS IS A ONE THAT REQUIRES A 5/7 ON FORMAL BIDDING, SO I HAVE TO PUT THAT IN THE MOTION. SO RETURN TO COMMISSION WITH A FAVORABLE RECOMMENDATION TO WAIVE THE 5/7 VOTE FOR THE FORMAL COMPETITIVE BIDDING REQUIREMENTS AS IN SECTION 2-367E OF THE CITY CODE, FINDING SUCH WAIVER TO BE IN THE BEST INTEREST OF THE CITY, AND APPROVE IN SUBSTANTIAL FORM THE PROPOSED NEW AGREEMENT WITH SODEXO AS PRESENTED, AND TO INCORPORATE OIG RECOMMENDATIONS. OKAY, SO WHO WOULD BE MAKING THAT MOTION? NO, THE CHAIR CANNOT MAKE THE MOTION.

THIS IS JUST TO MOVE IT TO COMMISSION, THIS WOULD JUST MOVE IT TO COMMISSION.

AS THIS PROCEEDS.

CORRECT.

OKAY, BECAUSE... I'LL MAKE THE MOTION.

I'LL SECOND.

ALL IN FAVOR? AYE.

ITEM PASSES 3 NOTHING. THANK YOU.

STEPHEN, WHILE WE HAVE YOU, PERHAPS, UH, WE'LL HEAR NB13.

[NB 13. A DISCUSSION REGARDING A SPONSORSHIP FOR EMERGE AMERICAS 2027, IN AN AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED $82,000]

OKAY. NB13, A DISCUSSION REGARDING A SPONSORSHIP FOR EMERGE AMERICAS 2027 IN AN AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED 82,000 DOLLARS. NB13.

THANK YOU, COMMITTEE. THANK YOU, CHAIR. ADMINISTRATION, THIS IS FOR EMERGE AMERICAS.

THIS IS OUR, OUR SPONSORSHIP THAT WE SPONSORED FOR EMERGE FOR THE LAST SEVERAL YEARS.

UM, WE'RE RECOMMENDING THE APPROVAL OF OUR SPONSORSHIP OF UP TO 80 THOUSAND, 82,000 DOLLARS. UM, THIS REQUIRES, YOU KNOW, THIS MAINTAINS OUR COMMITMENT, UH, TO THE, THE ECOSYSTEM, TECHNOLOGY INNOVATION ECOSYSTEM THAT WE BUILT HERE. THERE'S BEEN A NUMBER OF PROGRAMS, OF COURSE, THE, THE ANNUAL CONFERENCE EMERGE WAS BORN IN MIAMI BEACH, AND SO THIS IS THE MAINTAINING THAT, UH, THAT PARTNERSHIP. AND SO YOU'LL SEE THERE'S A NUMBER OF DIFFERENT KEY COMPONENTS THAT ARE INCLUDED IN THAT SPONSORSHIP. UM, THEIR ACCELERATOR STARTUP SHOWCASE, UM, THERE'S THE EMPOWER EVENT, WHICH ACTUALLY WAS JUST A JUDGE FOR, UH, LAST, LAST WEEK. UM, THEIR FOUNDERS DAY HAPPY HOUR, UH, WHERE WE ACTUALLY HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO MEET ONE-ON-ONE WITH A LOT OF THE CEOS

[00:20:02]

OF THOSE, OF THOSE COMPANIES.

UM, AND SO THERE IS ALSO THE EXPO SPACE, THE MIAMI AI SUMMIT, I MENTIONED THE, THE PITCH COMPETITION, AND A NUMBER OF DIFFERENT EVENTS WHERE, WHERE CERTAINLY, UM, IT GIVES NOT JUST, YOU KNOW, ALL OF US HERE AN OPPORTUNITY TO, TO INTERACT WITH THE FOLKS THAT ARE GOING TO BE THAT NEXT GROWING INDUSTRY FOR, FOR MIAMI BEACH, BUT IT'S CERTAINLY ALL OF YOU TO, TO PLACE YOU, YOU ALL IN FRONT OF, IN FRONT OF THAT GROUP AS WELL. AND SO THOSE ARE, IT COMPLETELY ALIGNS WITH OUR ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT, UH, PRIORITIES AS WELL, SO WE WERE ASKING FOR, UH, FOR A FAVORABLE RECOMMENDATION TO MOVE THIS FORWARD.

YEAH, THIS IS A TREMENDOUS EVENT, VERY IN LINE WITH, UH, WHERE WE WANT TO GO WITH THE CITY. UM, THE AMOUNT OF HEADS AND BEDS THAT THEY PROVIDE, THE AMOUNT OF ECONOMIC ACTIVITY, UH, IN THE SURROUNDING AREAS IS INCREDIBLE TO SEE. STEVEN, THIS ISN'T SPECIFIC TO EMERGE, UH, MAYBE IT'S A BROADER THEME, BUT A- AS THE ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT, I THINK ONE OF THE THINGS THAT PERHAPS WE COULD TALK MORE ABOUT, BUT WHAT I WOULD REALLY EXPLORE IN YOUR SHOES IS THE COSTS FOR SOME OF THESE LARGE CONFERENCES, EVENTS, AND THINGS LIKE THAT, BECAUSE, YOU KNOW, WHERE WE GET IS WE HAVE A LOT OF THEM COMING AND ASKING FOR SPONSORSHIP, AND, UH, YOU KNOW, A LOT OF THESE COSTS ARE BORN OR ARE CAUSED BY THE CITY, YOU KNOW, WHETHER IT BE EVENT FEES OR DIFFERENT TYPES OF FEES. UH, WE SHOULD REALLY EVALUATE THE COSTS THAT ARE INCURRED BY SOME OF THESE LARGE EVENTS BECAUSE IT, A LOT OF TIMES THEY'RE NOT JUST PASSED ON, IT COMES TO US WAIVING IT. SO WE SHOULD REALLY BE LOOKING AT THE PERSONNEL THAT WE HAVE FOR POLICE, FOR FIRE. IS THAT THE RIGHT PERSONNEL? UH, EVENT PERMITTING FEES, IS THAT, YOU KNOW, I JUST LOOKED AT SOME OF THE SMALLER EVENTS THAT WE HAD, AND AND THE AMOUNT OF MIAMI BEACH FEES THAT WE'RE CHARGING, UH, IS QUITE SUBSTANTIAL, AND THEN A LOT OF TIMES THEN WE'RE ASKED TO WAIVE IT. SO WE'RE KIND OF INCURRING THESE COSTS, AND THEN THEY'RE BORNE BY, UH, MIAMI BEACH. SO IT'S ALMOST LIKE CIRCULAR FINANCING, UH, IF YOU WILL. SO IT'S NOT SPECIFIC TO EMERGE, OF COURSE.

I THINK IT'S A BROADER CONVERSATION THAT WE SHOULD REALLY BE LOOKING IF WE'RE KIND OF STAFFING, UH, THE FEES WE'RE CHARGING FOR SOME OF THESE EVENTS, UM, BECAUSE IT IS AN ECONOMIC DRIVER, UH, ESPECIALLY WITH THE NEW CONVENTION CENTER HOTEL OPENING ONLINE. WE WANT TO BE COMPETITIVE IN THESE AREAS, ESPECIALLY, UH, IN A LOT OF CASES, UH, YOU KNOW, SOME OF THESE EVENTS, UH, THEY TURN AROUND AND THEN ASK US TO WAIVE THINGS OR ASK FOR SPONSOR- SPONSORSHIPS OR THINGS LIKE THAT, WHICH IS FINE, BUT WE SHOULD REALLY BE SURE THAT WE HAVE, UM, THE EFFICIENT COSTS THAT ARE BEING BORN HERE, UH, YOU KNOW, SO WE'RE NOT JUST TAKING OUT OF THE RIGHT POCKET AND PAYING WITH THE LEFT.

MAKES SENSE.

YEAH, BUT IN TERMS OF EMER, IT'S FULLY SUPPORTIVE, A GREAT EVENT, UH, AND IT'S, LIKE YOU SAID, BORN IN MIAMI BEACH, UM, AND THIS IS A TEAM THAT'S STARTING TO GET A NATIONAL, INTERNATIONAL RECOGNITION, UM, SO IT'S REALLY A GREAT KIND OF A FLAG FOR OUR CITY.

SO I THINK WE'D BE, IF AT THAT TIME, WE'D BE LOOKING FOR A, UH, RECOMMEND- A MOTION TO RECON- UH, RETURN TO COMMISSION WITH A FAVORABLE RECOMMENDATION TO APPROVE THE SPONSORSHIP FOR EMERGE AMERICAS 2027, UH, AS AS PRESENTED.

YES.

I'LL MAKE THE MOTION.

AND I'LL SECOND. ALL IN FAVOR? AYE.

ITEM PASSES. THANK YOU.

COMMISSIONER MATTEO-SALINAS, DO YOU WANT TO HEAR NB7? I BELIEVE THAT'S YOU, RIGHT? UH, OR IS THAT YOU, COMMISSIONER DOMINGUEZ? I APOLOGIZE.

THAT'S FINE.

[NB 7. DISCUSS REPAINTING THE EXTRA-TALL LIGHT POLES ON LINCOLN ROAD]

OH, WANT TO HEAR THAT? NB7.

NB7, DISCUSS REPAINTING EXTRA TALL LIGHT POLES ON LINCOLN ROAD. NB7.

SO I HAD MET WITH THE LINCOLN ROAD, UM, BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT, AND AT THE TIME, THE LIGHT POLES WERE IN ROUGH SHAPE AND NEEDED PAINT. UH, I BELIEVE THERE WERE 14 OF THEM IN TOTAL. SINCE THEN, THERE WAS, UM, A POP-UP THAT PAINTED 2 OF THE LIGHT POLES, AND IN MEETINGS WITH CIP, THE BID WAS TOLD THAT THE COST OF PAINTING A FEW MORE COULD BE INCORPORATED INTO THE PROJECTS THAT ARE CURRENTLY HAPPENING.

UM, DAVID GOMEZ CAN GIVE US AN UPDATE.

HI, GOOD MORNING, UH, MR. CHAIR, COMMISSIONERS. DAVID GOMEZ, DIRECTOR OF THE OFFICE OF CAPITAL IMPROVEMENTS. THERE ARE, TO OUR COUNT, 9 LIGHT POLES THAT, THAT COULD BE PAINTED FOR IMPROVEMENT. WE ARE UNSURE, BECAUSE OF THE HEIGHT OF THE POLES AND WHAT EXISTING PAINT THEY HAVE, WHAT THAT COST WOULD BE. SO WE HAVE INCLUDED AN ALTERNATE ITEM ON THE BID FOR PHASE 3, UH, TO, IN ORDER TO GET THAT PRICE AND BE ABLE TO GIVE YOU AN INFORMED, UH, BASIS FOR THE COST OF PAINTING THE, THE POLES.

SO SHOULD WE LEAVE THIS, SHOULD WE LEAVE IT HERE FOR, UM, ANOTHER MONTH TO HAVE WHAT THE COST WOULD BE? THE RECOMMENDATION ON THE MEMO IS TO TAKE IT BACK TO COMMISSION TO DISCUSS FOR AWARD SO THAT WE CAN SPEED UP THE AWARD OF PHASE 3. BUT AS OF YESTERDAY, WE ISSUED A, AN

[00:25:02]

A, AN ADDENDUM TO THE BID THAT DELAYED THE, THE BID DATE. SO WE WILL BE ABLE TO COME BACK TO THIS COMMITTEE TO, TO PROVIDE THAT INFORMATION.

SO IS IT SOMETHING THAT I NEED TO BE MINDFUL OF FOR TONIGHT'S MEETING? UH, I DON'T THINK SO. IT IT'S, WELL, DEPENDING ON WHAT THE COMMITTEE RECOMMENDS TO COMMISSION, WE MAY NEED TO FIND ADDITIONAL FUNDING. I HAVE NO IDEA AT THIS POINT WHAT THE COST PROPOSAL WILL BE. UM, WE'LL HAVE THAT INFORMATION AT THE NEXT FINANCE MEETING.

SO FOR TONIGHT'S MEETING, SHOULD I MARK ANYTHING? LIKE WHAT? WITHOUT A BASIS FOR HOW MUCH YOU WOULD NEED TO SET ASIDE, I, I WOULDN'T BE ABLE TO GIVE YOU A GOOD RECOMMENDATION. THESE POLES ARE SOMEWHERE BETWEEN 40 AND 70 FEET HIGH. IT'S GOING TO REQUIRE SPECIALTY EQUIPMENT.

IT COULD HAVE EXISTING LEAD-BASED PAINT, WHICH COULD NEED TO BE MITIGATED. THE, THE MANNER IN WHICH THEY'RE PAINTED, WHETHER IT'S ELECTROSTATIC OR EPOXY OR OTHER MATERIALS, THAT STILL NEEDS TO BE IRONED OUT. WE, IN OUR BID, SPECIFIED A, A QUALITY FINISH THAT WILL LAST A WHILE.

MR. CFO, WHAT DO YOU RECOMMEND? UH, I- IT SEEMS AS IS, SINCE THERE'S REALLY IS NO BASIS TO KNOW EXACTLY WHAT THAT NUMBER IS, I THINK FOR, FOR, FOR TONIGHT'S PURPOSES, IT MAY BE, I THINK THERE'S AROUND 1 MILLION DOLLARS THAT'S IN THAT BUDGET, UH, STABILIZATION RESERVE FOR NEXT YEAR, AND, YOU KNOW, THERE MAY BE DISCUSSIONS ABOUT ADDING OTHER ITEMS, NOT KNOWING WHAT THIS NUMBER WOULD BE, THE MAYBE THE BEST TACTIC IS TRY TO PRESERVE AS MUCH OF THAT, UH, THOSE DOLLARS AS POSSIBLE, SO THAT WHEN ITEMS COME UP DURING THE YEAR, SUCH AS THIS ONE, THERE IS THE CAPACITY TO UTILIZE THOSE FUNDS. SO, YEAH.

OKAY, SO IF, UH, SEND TO THE NEXT COMMISSION MEETING FOR TONIGHT, WE DON'T HAVE DOLLARS TO EARMARK IT, AND, UM, NEXT YEAR, WHEN WE KNOW WHAT THE AMOUNTS ARE, SEE IF THERE'S AN APPETITE WITH THE COMMISSION TO TAKE IT.

FROM THE BUDGET STABILIZATION RESERVE. AND IF I CAN, IS IT, IS THE RECOMMENDATION, IS THERE TIME TO COME TO THE OCTOBER FERC TO HEAR THE NUMBER? THERE IS. WE CAN COME BACK TO OCTOBER AND THEN DO THE AWARD FOR THE CONTRACT IN NOVEMBER AT COMMISSION.

SO IF YOU WANT, UM, THE SPONSOR, WE COULD, UH, SHOW THIS ITEM IS HEARD AND TO RETURN IN OCTOBER FOR FINAL DISPOSITION. IT SOUNDS LIKE THE IMPLEMENTING DEPARTMENT HAS THAT ABILITY AND NOT TO MESS WITH THE TIMELINE.

YEAH.

OKAY.

SO, CHAIR, WE'LL SHOW THIS ITEM HEARD AND TO RETURN IN OCTOBER. THANK YOU.

THANK YOU FOR THAT. UM, COMMISSIONER FERNANDEZ, DO YOU WANT TO HEAR NB9, THE GRANT TO WORLD AFFAIRS COUNCIL FOR APRIL 2026?

[NB 9. CONSIDER A GRANT TO THE WORLD AFFAIRS COUNCIL IN AN AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED $6,000 IN SUPPORT OF THEIR SPONSORSHIP OF THE ATTENDANCE BY MIAMI BEACH SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS TO THE ACADEMIC WORLDQUEST CHAMPIONSHIP IN WASHINGTON, D.C., IN APRIL 2026.]

SURE.

MB9, CONSIDER A- UH, I NEED TO RECUSE MYSELF AND STEP OUT OF THE ROOM.

OKAY.

UH, MB9, CONSIDER A GRANT TO THE WORLD AFFAIRS COUNCIL IN AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED $6,000 IN SUPPORT OF THEIR SPONSORSHIP FOR THE ATTENDANCE BY MIAMI BEACH SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS TO THE ACADEMIC WORLD QUEST CHAMPIONSHIP IN WASHINGTON, DC IN APRIL 2026.

UH, MB9.

I'D LIKE TO MOVE THE ITEM, GREAT ITEM, COMMISSIONER. OR DO YOU WANT TO PRESENT IT? NO, THIS IS ONLY TO ALLOW FOR SOME STUDENTS FROM MIAMI BEACH SENIOR HIGH TO GO TO WASHINGTON, DC AND PARTICIPATE IN THIS ACTIVITY.

FULLY SUPPORT. I'D LOVE TO CO-SPONSOR IF I CAN, IF IT'S NOT TOO LATE.

OF COURSE.

LOVE THIS.

SO I- IS THE ITEM TO RETURN TO COMMISSION WITH A FAVORABLE RECOMMENDATION TO DIRECT THE SPONSORSHIP, AND THEN IF IT GETS APPROVED BY COMMISSION, THAT WE'D RETURN WITH A BUDGET AMENDMENT THE FOLLOWING MONTH TO APPROPRIATE DOLLARS FOR THAT, OR THE SPONSOR COULD BRING IT UP TONIGHT. UM, I'LL LEAVE IT UP TO THE COMMITTEE OR AND OR THE SPONSOR ON HOW THEY WANT TO, UH...

THE WILL OF THE COMMITTEE. WE HAVE THE, UH, BRING IT UP TONIGHT.

THE BUDGET BOSS.

UM... I'M CAUTIOUS ABOUT TONIGHT OF JUST BEING A FREE FOR ALL. I THINK PANDORA'S BOX MAY ALREADY BE OPEN, SO P- PERHAPS MAYBE WE. MAYBE WE JUST PLAY IT BY EAR.

EXACTLY.

IT JUST, YEAH, I THINK THERE'S A FEW KEY COMMUNITY THINGS MM-HMM.

THAT I THINK WE SHOULD HIGHLIGHT TONIGHT, BUT I DO WANT TO BE COGNIZANT ABOUT AT LEAST STAYING IN LINE WITH WHERE WE WERE.

YEAH.

AND I DON'T KNOW ABOUT TIMING OF THIS, UM, IT'S 6,000 DOLLARS. IT'S OBVIOUSLY YOU'RE GOING TO HAVE FULL SUPPORT OF THIS. UH, IF WE'RE ABLE TO DO, HEY, THIS IS VERY QUICK, ALONG WITH SOME OF THE OTHER ITEMS THAT WE'LL BE HEARING, UH, PERHAPS PANDORA'S BOX IS ALREADY OPEN, AND IT WON'T MATTER.

AND MR. CHAIR, TO YOUR POINT, UM, I'M, I'M JUST GOING TO USE THIS OPPORTUNITY TO PUT OUT THERE, UH, YESTERDAY I HAD A MEETING WITH CLEAN MIAMI BEACH, UH, THAT I DON'T KNOW THAT, THAT THEY'VE STILL HAVE BEEN, HAVE MADE THEIR WAY, UH, INTO THE B- INTO THE FINAL BUDGET. IT'S JUST OF UNINTENDED CIRCUMSTANCES THAT, UH, THE, THAT, THAT WENT ON OVER AT CLEAN MIAMI BEACH, BUT I KNOW THAT THAT'S AN ENTITY THAT WE ALL LOVE, UM, AND THAT DOES INCREDIBLY BE- BEYOND US, YOU KNOW, LOVING

[00:30:01]

THEM, YOU KNOW, THEY DO JUST INCREDIBLE WORK, UH, IN OUR CO- COMMUNITY. SO TO YOUR POINT, YOU KNOW, THERE'S GOING TO BE A NUMBER OF THINGS THAT ARE GOING TO COME UP, UH, TONIGHT.

SO PERHAPS TO MAYBE PLAY IT SAFE FOR, FOR THE, TO CLOSE THIS ITEM OUT, IS WE CAN HAVE IT KIND OF BOTH WAYS. IF IT GETS RESOLVED TONIGHT, IT GETS RESOLVED TONIGHT, BUT PERHAPS THE MOTION OUT OF THIS COMMITTEE BE RETURNED TO COMMISSION WITH A FAVORABLE RECOMMENDATION TO DIRECT ADMINISTRATION EXECUTE A SPONSORSHIP AGREEMENT AS PRESENTED. AND IF IT COMES UP TONIGHT, THIS BECOMES A MOOT POINT, AND THE EXECUTING DEPARTMENT DOESN'T ACTUALLY HAVE TO BRING THIS BACK TO COMMISSION BECAUSE IT'LL BE DEALT WITH TONIGHT. IF IT DOESN'T COME UP TONIGHT, THEN WE WOULD BRING, UH, AN ACTUAL RESOLUTION SO IT CAN BE DISPOSED OF THAT WAY. SO YOU'LL BE COVERED EITHER WAY. I THINK THAT MIGHT BE THE SAFEST WAY TO GO. UM, SO SEEING THAT, I'M GOING TO SHOW, BASED ON THE ATTENDANCE AND PROTOCOL, THAT COMMISSIONER MONI- MONICA SALINAS WOULD HAVE TO MAKE THE MOTION. UH, HOLD ON, I THINK RICK WANTS TO SAY SOMETHING.

YES, THROUGH THE CHAIR. I BELIEVE THE ITEM WILL STILL NEED TO RETURN TO COMMISSION TO APPROVE THE SPONSORSHIP AGREEMENT, EVEN IF YOU APPROVE THE FUNDING FOR IT TONIGHT.

OKAY. SO, THANK YOU, RICK.

SO, UH, I THINK JUST FOR PROTOCOL, WE'RE GONNA HAVE TO SHOW, UH, COMMISSIONER MONICA SALINAS AS, AS THE, UM, MAKING THE MOTION AND, UH, THE CHAIR MAKING THE SECOND, SINCE WE JUST HAVE TWO AT THIS POINT. UH, ALL IN FAVOR? AYE.

AYE.

THE ITEM PASSES 2 NOTHING, 1 ABSTAIN. THANK YOU.

I DON'T WANT TO LEAVE COMMISSIONER DOMINGUEZ HANGING.

MAYBE WE COULD SIGNAL TO, SIGNAL TO HER THAT, UH, ITEM HAS BEEN HEARD. UM, COMMISSIONER DOMINGUEZ, WHY DON'T WE HEAR TOGETHER, UH, NB6 RESTAURANT DISCLOSURE ON SERVICE CHARGES? AND, UH, MR. CFO, I DON'T KNOW IF YOU WANT TO INTRODUCE THAT, BUT HAPPY TO KIND OF TEE THAT UP.

[NB 6. DISCUSS AND EVALUATE THE FEASIBILITY OF REQUIRING ALL FOOD SERVICE ESTABLISHMENTS TO CLEARLY DISCLOSE, THROUGH A BRIGHT STAMP AT THE TOP OF CUSTOMER RECEIPTS, WHEN GRATUITY OR SERVICES CHARGES ARE AUTOMATICALLY INCLUDED.]

UH, NB6, DISCUSS AND EVALUATE THE FEASIBILITY OF REQUIRING ALL FOOD, UM, FOOD SERVICE ESTABLISHMENTS TO CLEARLY DISCLOSE THROUGH A BRIGHT STAMP AT THE TOP OF CUSTOMER SEATS WHERE GRATUITY OR SERVICE CHARGES ARE AUTOMATICALLY INCLUDED. UH, MB6. UH, I DO, WE HAVE CODE WHO GO THROUGH IT, BUT I DO KNOW THAT THERE WAS A NEW STATE LAW THAT WAS IMPLEMENTED THAT ADDRESSED SOME OF THESE ISSUES, BUT IT MAY NOT BE EVERYTHING.

YEAH.

BUT I THINK WE HAVE CODE HERE THAT CAN GO THROUGH THE NUANCES OF THAT.

Y- YOU KNOW, UH, KIND OF WHAT, WHAT TIPPING IS BEING APPLIED TO OR ADDED TO IS, UH, BECOMING MORE OF A BROADER SOCIETAL ISSUE.

UH, THIS ISN'T MEANT TO ADDRESS THAT, UH, BUT IT IS VERY UNIQUE IN MIAMI AND MIAMI BEACH, UH, THAT MANY TIMES AT SOME OF OUR RESTAURANTS, ESPECIALLY MORE TOURIST DRIVEN LOCATIONS, THAT AN AUTOMATIC GRATUITY CHARGE IS ADDED.

AND, YOU KNOW, THE, THE EXPLANATION FOR THAT IS WE ARE AN INTERNATIONAL TOURIST DESTINATION, AND IN MANY OTHER CULTURES, UH, TIPPING ISN'T, UH, PERCEIVED THE SAME WAY OR APPLIED THE SAME WAY AS IT IS HERE IN THE UNITED STATES. SO THAT'S ALMOST TO PROTECT, UH, THE EMPLOYEES.

UM, BUT WHAT I DON'T WANT TO GET INTO IS, UH, THROUGH IGNORANCE OF PEOPLE NOT KNOWING THAT SERVICE CHARGES APPLIED, THAT ESSENTIALLY, UH, AN ADDITIONAL GRATUITY IS BEING ADDED. AND NOWADAYS, AND I'M NOT SUGGESTING THERE'S ANYTHING NEFARIOUS GOING ON, BUT, UH, YOU START GETTING INTO THIS AMBIGUITY, EVEN IF YOU ASK, WELL, IS THERE A TIP INCLUDED? UH, YOU KNOW, THERE SEEMS TO BE, WELL, THIS IS A SERVICE CHARGE AND NOT... IF THERE'S AN ADDITIONAL SERVICE CHARGE THAT IS ADDED ONTO THE BILL, I THINK THAT SHOULD BE MORE CLEARLY DISCLOSED BECAUSE WHETHER IT BE RESIDENTS OR VISITORS, THEY SHOULD KNOW EXACTLY WHAT IS BEING CHARGED AND APPLIED, UH, BECAUSE WE DON'T WANT TO TAKE ADVANTAGE FROM OF PEOPLE FROM IGNORANCE. AND JUST VERY PLAINLY, A LOT OF TIMES, ESPECIALLY IN THE MORE TOURIST DRIVEN AREAS, YOU'LL GO AND YOU'LL PAY A BILL, AND A LOT OF PEOPLE, WITHOUT THINKING OR LOOKING AT THE BILL, WILL GIVE AN EXTRA 20%, AND THEY DON'T KNOW THAT THAT, UH, SERVICE CHARGE HAS ALREADY BEEN INCLUDED. AND, YOU KNOW, UH, THE FREE MARKET ALWAYS KIND OF, UH, FIND A WAY AHEAD, AND THERE'S CLEVER WAYS TO DISGUISE SOME OF THESE DIFFERENT, UH, TIPS AND CHARGES AND THINGS LIKE THAT. UM, SO IF WE'RE ADDING ON, NOT WE, IF A RESTAURANT OR A HOTEL IS ADDING ON ADDITIONAL SERVICE CHARGES OVER, ABOVE AND BEYOND THE, UH, ORIGINAL BILL, WE SHOULD FIND A METHOD TO CLEARLY DISCLOSE THAT. WE COULD TALK ABOUT WHAT THAT IS, WHETHER IT'S HIGHLIGHTED AT THE TOP OF THE RECEIPT, WHETHER IT'S BLOCKED OUT IN BOLD RED, UH, LETTERS.

MAYBE WE'LL LEAVE THAT TO STAFF ABOUT WHAT THAT SHOULD LOOK LIKE, BUT, UH, TURN IT OVER TO STAFF UNLESS COMMISSIONER, YEP, YEAH, HAPPY TO, UH, UH, TURN THAT OVER TO YOU AS WELL.

THANK YOU. UH, AGREE WITH EVERYTHING YOU JUST SAID.

UH, WE DO HAVE A LOT OF INTERNATIONAL TOURISTS THAT ARE COMING FROM COUNTRIES WHERE TIP IS INCLUDED, AND WHAT BOTHERS ME, AND I SEE IT HAPPENING IN SOME RESTAURANTS ACROSS THE BEACH, IS THAT THE 20% GRATUITY IS AUTOMATICALLY INCLUDED, AND THEN THE BILL

[00:35:02]

WILL COME AND IT'LL SAY TIP, WHERE IT SHOULD SAY ADDITIONAL TIP, BECAUSE ON WHAT PLANET DO THEY THINK THAT PEOPLE ARE GOING TO PAY 40% ON TOP OF THEIR BILL? UM, AND I KNOW THAT WE HAVE A REQUIREMENT IN OUR CODE WHERE THEY HAVE TO DISPLAY IT ON THE MENUS, AND IT HAS TO SAY IT SPECIFICALLY, BUT IT SHOULD ALSO SAY IT ON THE RECEIPT, THAT IF IT'S ADDITIONAL TIP, YOU WOULDN'T JUST HAVE, UH, PLUS TIP.

AND ONE THING I'LL ALSO ASK, ARE THERE LAWS THAT ARE AROUND WHAT A RESTAURANT CAN COLLECT OUT OF THE TIP? BECAUSE IT SEEMS LIKE JUST IN THE PAST YEAR, I- IF YOU ASK A SERVER, OH, IS TIP ALREADY INCLUDED? THEY'LL SAY, YES, BUT THIS KIND OF GETS, UH, SPLIT AMONGST THE HOUSE AND THINGS LIKE THAT. UM, IT KIND OF LEAVES THE CUSTOMER IN A WEIRD POSITION, LIKE, WAIT, I'M BEING CHARGED A 20% TIP, BUT MY SERVER'S BEING TOLD THAT DOESN'T GO TO THEM. JOE, MAYBE THAT'S MAKING YOU MOVE AROUND A LOT TODAY. I APOLOGIZE. THANK YOU. JOSEPH SANTORINO, INSPECTOR GENERAL.

I'M GLAD THE COMMISSION IS TAKING UP THIS ISSUE, AND UH, WE HAVE A PERSPECTIVE ON IT FROM THIS STANDPOINT OF RESORT TAXES, AND WE, UM, WE AUDIT, UH, THE RESORT TAXPAYERS, UH, AS YOU KNOW, AND WITHOUT GETTING INTO DETAIL AS TO ANY SPECIFIC, UH, AUDIT WE'VE DONE, WE HAVE, WE HAVE FOUND THAT, YOU KNOW, THERE ARE, UH, THERE ARE, ARE RESTAURANTS AND ESTABLISHMENTS, YOU KNOW, CHARGING THE 20% UH, SERVICE CHARGE. THAT IS UNDER STATE LAW, THAT'S TAXABLE, THAT AS SALES TAX AND RESORT TAX. SOME RESTAURANTS PAY THE RESORT TAX OUT OF THAT, AND SOME DON'T. UM, AND WE'VE, IT'S COME UP A NUMBER OF TIMES IN DIFFERENT AUDITS, UM, AND I AGREE THAT IT, IT, IT, IT CREATES A SITUATION WHERE, YOU KNOW, PEOPLE DON'T KNOW WHAT THE SERVICE CHARGE IS GOING TO. THERE ARE, THERE ARE, THERE ARE RESTAURANTS THAT, THAT CLAIM THAT THEY GIVE IT TO THE, UH, TO THE EMPLOYEES, BUT SOME OF THE, THE, THE GIVING HAS TO DO, YOU KNOW, IS IN THE FORM OF, WELL, WE PAY FOR THE UNIFORMS. WE, WE, WE PAY FOR THINGS THAT, THAT, YOU KNOW, WE, IN ONE CASE, PAY FOR BIRTHDAY PRESENTS FOR THE STAFF, YOU KNOW, SO WE THERE'S A, WE WE'RE REALLY GETTING INTO SOME, SOME, UH, SOME DIFFICULTIES WITH SOME OF THESE, UH, AND THE THE IDEA OF MAKING IT VERY CLEAR IF THE SERV- THERE'S ONE THAT IS THAT CLAIMS THAT THE SERVICE CHARGE IS OPTIONAL, BUT IT DOESN'T SAY THAT. SO IF IT'S AN OPTIONAL CHARGE, IT OUGHT TO BE, IT OUGHT TO STATE IT'S AN OPTIONAL CHARGE.

IF IT'S A GRATUITY, IT OUGHT TO STATE THAT IT'S A GRATUITY. I W- THIS, THIS REALLY NEEDS TO BE CLEARED UP, NOT ONLY FOR THE CONSUMER, BUT FOR THE CITY'S OWN INTEREST IN COLLECTING RESORT TAXES.

APPRECIATE THAT. AND RICK, WHAT, WHAT IS THE STATE INITIATIVE, AND THEN COMMISSIONER FERNANDEZ, BUT UH, RICK, WHAT, WHAT IS THE STATE, UM, AS THE CFO POINTED OUT, AND I, I THINK THEY HAVE SOME SORT OF INITIATIVE, UH, ALONG THE SAME LINES HERE.

YEAH, UM, THROUGH THE CHAIR, UM, IN 2025, THE S- THE LEGISLATURE ADOPTED, UM, REQUIREMENTS FOR FOOD SERVICE ESTABLISHMENTS. UH, THEY NEED TO DISCLOSE THE AMOUNT OF PERCENTAGE OF ANY OPERATIONS CHARGE, WHICH IS DEFINED UNDER THE BILL TO INCLUDE ANY HOUSE CHARGES OR OPERATIONS CHARGES. IT ALSO INCLUDES AUTOMATIC GRATUITIES, ET CETERA. UM, THE, IF, IF THE OPERATIONS CHARGE INCLUDES AN AUTOMATIC GRATUITY, THAT NEEDS TO BE CLEARLY STATED. UM, THIS, THIS IS REQUIRED BOTH ON THE MENU, IF THE RESTAURANT HAS A WEBSITE, IT'S REQUIRED ON THE WEBSITE, UM, AND THEN ALSO ON THE RECEIPT, THERE HAS TO BE A SEPARATE LINE FOR GRATUITY, FOR OPERATIONS CHARGES, AND FOR TAX. UM, ONE OTHER POINT, UH, TO THE QUESTION THAT YOU ASKED EARLIER, IF THERE'S ANY LAWS, UM, UNDER FEDERAL TAX LAW, IF THERE'S AN AUTOMATIC CHARGE, UM, THEN THE RESTAURANT CANNOT TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THE TIP CREDIT. I DON'T KNOW THAT THAT REALLY MATTERS FOR PURPOSES, BUT UH, BUT THAT WAS JUST A FOOTNOTE.

COMMISSIONER FERNANDEZ.

UH, THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR. SO, MR. MR. ATTORNEY, SO WHEN W- WHEN THIS NEW LAW WENT INTO EFFECT, DID THE REST- DID THE RESTAURANTS NEED TO DISCLOSE WHETHER THE OPERATION CHARGE THAT'S BEING CHARGED ON THE, UH, ON THE TICKET, WHETHER THAT IS A GRATUITY OR WHETHER IT'S RETAINED BY THE B- BY THE RESTAURANT, OR S- OR IS THERE STILL AMBIGUITY ON THAT? SO, UM, SO IF THE, IF THERE'S AN AUTOMATIC OPERATIONS CHARGE THAT INCLUDES A GRATUITY, THEN THE, IT NEEDS TO BE STATED SEPARATELY, THE,

[00:40:01]

THE ACTUAL BUT WHAT IF WHEN IT'S NOT A GRATUITY? BECAUSE OFTENTIMES A CONSUMER MAY, MAY SEE AN OPERATIONS CHARGE AND JUST ASSUME IT'S GRATUITY, BUT OFTENTIMES IT'S NOT GRATUITY AND IS RETAINED BY THE RESTAURANT FOR OPERATIONAL COSTS.

RIGHT. UM, IF, IF, IF THERE'S AN AUTOMATIC GRATUITY INCLUDED, IT NEEDS TO BE STEP- SEPARATELY STATED.

OKAY, BUT THE OPPOSITE, BUT THE REVERSE IS NOT. PJ, DO YOU HAVE- IF IT SAYS 20% OPERATIONS CHARGE AND DOESN'T, DOESN'T SPECIFY THAT THERE'S AN AUTOMATIC GRATUITY, IF THERE IS AN AUTOMATIC GRATUITY, THEN THE, THE RESTAURANT IS IN VIOLATION OF, OF THE LAW.

PJ, UH, YEAH, BUT THAT'S ONLY FOR THE CONSUMER THAT KNOWS THE LAW, UH, AND KNOWS WHAT NEEDS TO BE DISCLOSED OR NOT. A, A WHILE BACK, WE WERE, UH, MR. ATTORNEY, YOUR, YOUR OFFICE AND I, WE WERE, WE WERE WORKING ON LEGISLATION ON THIS MATTER, UH, AND THEN THERE WERE QUESTIONS ABOUT THE PREEMPTION, AND PERHAPS THESE ARE RECOMMENDATIONS THAT COULD BE INCORPORATED INTO THE WORK THAT YOU'RE DOING, MR. CHAIR. UH, BUT PERHAPS ASKING THOSE INDIVIDUALS, UM, AND AT THIS POINT WOULDN'T EVEN BE JUST CONCESSIONAIRES OF THE CITY, BECAUSE I BELIEVE THAT THIS LAW GIVES THE CITY THE ABILITY TO ACTUALLY ENTER INTO CERTAIN REQUIREMENTS OF RESTAURATEURS GENERALLY, UM, BUT ACTUALLY REQUIRING OUR RESTAURATEURS TO SELECT ONE OF THESE AS DISCLOSURES ON, ON THEIR, ON THEIR RECEIPTS.

UH, ONE OPTION BEING THIS OPERATION CHARGE IS NOT A GRATUITY, IS RETAINED BY THE RESTAURANT FOR OPERATIONAL COSTS, AND IS NOT DISTRIBUTED TO SERVICE STAFF, SO THAT THEY UNDERSTAND SPECIFICALLY HOW THAT ESTABLISHMENT IS USING, UH, THE TH- THOSE DOLLARS.

THEN A SECOND OPTION, THIS OPERATIONS CHARGE IS DISTRIBUTED IN WHOLE AND IN PART TO SERVICE STAFF. IT IS NOT A SUBSTITUTE FOR A TIP, AND YOU MAY LEAVE AN ADDITIONAL GRATUITY AT YOUR DISCRETION.

OR A THIRD OPTION, THAT THIS OPERATIONS CHARGE IS PAID ENTIRELY TO SERVICE STAFF IN LIEU OF A TR- OF A TRADITIONAL TIP. NO ADDITIONAL GRATUITY IS EXPECTED OR REQUIRED. SO THAT WAY THEY GET CERTAIN CLARITY, A CERTAIN, YOU KNOW, TO A CERTAIN EXTENT, SOME SORT OF DEFINITION, UH, AS TO, AS TO HOW THAT NEW LINE THAT'S APPEARING ON THEIR, ON THEIR RECEIPT IS BEING APPLIED.

YEAH, AND ALSO, TH- THOSE ARE ALL GOOD AND HAPPY TO INCORPORATE THAT, COMMISSIONER. WHAT WOULD MY COLLEAGUES FEEL, AND I WANT TO GET, UH, CITY STAFF'S EXPERT OPINION, UH, HAVING SOME SORT OF, REQUIRING SOME SORT OF UNIFORMITY, UH, ALERT ALMOST, IF YOU WILL, ON A RECEIPT. AND THEN I GUESS WE'LL HAVE TO EVEN GET MORE NUANCED, UH, AS THERE'S A LOT OF POINT OF SALE, UH, SYSTEMS WHERE IF THERE IS A GRATUITY INCLUDED, WE COULD MAYBE LEAVE IT TO STAFF OR DISCUSS AMONGST US HOW THAT IS IMMEDIATELY BROUGHT TO THE ATTENTION OF THE CONSUMER, WHETHER IT IS A RED STAMP AT THE TOP OF THE RECEIPT SAYING, UH, SEE BELOW, GRATUITY INCLUDED, OR WHATEVER THAT DISCLOSURE MAY BE. UM, BUT MAYBE ONE OF MY PRIMARY, UH, GOALS AND OBJECTIVES HERE IS TO IMMEDIATELY BRING THAT TO THE AWARENESS OF THE CONSUMER SO THEY'RE NOT DOUBLE CHARGED, THAT THERE IS SOME SORT OF GRATUITY THAT'S ALREADY INCLUDED. SO PERHAPS WE LOOK AT SOME SORT OF UNIFORM DISCLOSURE ALERT, UH, WHERE IT WOULD MOST LIKELY BE SEEN. UM.

I HAVE A QUESTION. UM, SO IF SO- IF SOMEBODY, IF A RESTAURANT HAS A 20% AND THEY SAY THAT THAT DOESN'T COVER THE GRATUITY, UM, I PERSONALLY THINK THAT'S WRONG. THEY SHOULDN'T MAKE THAT THE COST, UH, INCREASE THE COST OF YOUR MEALS AND DRINKS, UH, BUT DON'T KEEP ADDING. ARE WE ALLOWED TO LEGISLATE, UH, SAYING YOU CAN'T CHARGE ANYTHING OTHER THAN THE SERVICE CHARGE? I THINK THAT GETS TO RICK, AND THAT'S WHERE I WAS GOING WITH THIS, BECAUSE IT SEEMS MORE AND MORE COMMON NOW IF YOU ASK, IS GRATUITY INCLUDED? AND THE SERVICE STAFF, THROUGH NO FAULT OF THEIR OWN, SAYS, YES, BUT THAT'S KIND OF SPLIT AMONGST AND DIFFERENT THINGS, AND I HEAR FURTHER HORROR STORIES FROM PEOPLE THAT WORK IN THESE INDUSTRIES ABOUT HOW MUCH OF THE TIP POSSIBLY GETS DISTRIBUTED AMONGST STAFF, OR PERHAPS THE THINGS LIKE JOE SAYS, CREATIVE, UH, FINANCIAL ENGINEERING BY SOME OF THESE SOPHISTICATED OR NON-SOPHISTICATED OPERATORS SAYING, WELL, IT'S NOT COMING TO US, BUT WE'RE PAYING FOR BIRTHDAY PARTIES OR THINGS LIKE THAT, THAT SEEMS A BIT PREDATORY TO ME. UH, RICK, LET ME TURN THAT OVER TO YOU, BECAUSE I FEEL AS IF WE'RE GETTING INTO LIKE SOME FEDERAL LAW THAT SHOULD BE FOLLOWED, BUT PERHAPS IS NOT.

RIGHT. AND GOING BACK TO THE, I THINK THE QUESTION COMMISSIONER DOMINGUEZ ASKED IS WHETHER WE COULD REGULATE WHAT RESTAURANTS CHARGE, AND THE ANSWER TO THAT IS, IS A STRAIGHTFORWARD NO. WE DON'T HAVE THE AUTHORITY TO DO THAT. WE'RE PREEMPTED BY THE STATE ON THE REGULATION OF, OF THE, UM, YOU KNOW, RESTAURANTS AND HOTELS. UM, THE, YOU KNOW, THE, THE NEW LAW

[00:45:01]

OPENED AN OPPORTUNITY FOR THE CITY TO ENHANCE WHAT THE REQUIREMENTS ARE, UM, AND THAT IS, YOU KNOW, WHAT THE SUBJECT OF THIS ITEM IS, OF COURSE.

AND I'LL LEAVE IT TO EITHER JOE OR RICK. IF A RESTAURANT IS FOLLOWING THE LETTER OF THE LAW AND THEY SAY 20% AUTOMATIC GRATUITY CHARGED, DOES THAT HAVE TO GO TO THE SERVER? IS THAT ABLE TO BE SPLIT AMONGST, UH, STAFF THAT IS NOT MAKING MINIMUM WAGE BECAUSE, UH, TIPS ARE INCLUDED, OR CAN THAT REALLY BE AT THEIR DISCRETION ABOUT HOW THAT IS DISTRIBUTED? BECAUSE THAT, THAT IMPACTS A LOT OF OUR RESIDENTS THAT ARE WORKING IN THIS SERVICE INDUSTRY.

SO IF, IF IT SAYS AUTOMATIC GRATUITY, THE UNDERSTANDING IS THAT IT SHOULD BE ONLY DISTRIBUTED TO TIPPED STAFF, WHICH WOULD INCLUDE, YOU KNOW, SERVERS, UH, RUNNERS, EXPEDITERS, IF YOU'RE DEALING WITH BARTENDERS, THE BARTENDER, THE BAR BACKS. UM, SO AT LEAST MY UNDERSTANDING IS THAT IF, IF IT'S A, IF IT'S A GRATUITY AND THE BUSINESS IS TAKING WHAT I REFERRED TO EARLIER, WHICH IS THE TIP CREDIT WHERE THE EMPLOYEE IS RECEIVING LESS THAN THE STANDARD MINIMUM WAGE, THEN, UM, YOU KNOW, THAT WOULD BE A MATTER OF, YOU KNOW, FRAUD IF, IF THE RESTAURANT IS NOT DISTRIBUTING IT TO ITS EMPLOYEES.

AND THAT PROBABLY HASN'T CHANGED MUCH OVER THE YEARS, BUT PERHAPS STAFF HAS JUST, UH, BEEN MORE FORTHCOMING THAT, HEY, THIS DOESN'T ALL GO DIRECTLY TO THE WAITER OR WAITRESS.

AND I BELIEVE THE ISSUE THAT YOU'RE DESCRIBING, WHICH IS SOMETHING THAT WHEN COMMISSIONER FERNANDEZ FIRST STARTED WORKING WITH US ON, ON THOSE OPTIONS, IS THAT IF IT'S A SERVICE CHARGE, THEN IT IT'S A LITTLE GRAYER IN TERMS OF IS IT IF IS IT ALL GOING TO THE REST, IS IS IT ALL GOING TO THE SERVERS OR NOT? AND YEAH, I'VE HEARD THE SAME THAT SOME RESTAURANTS WILL TAKE, YOU KNOW, HALF OF IT AND KEEP IT FOR THEIR OWN, YOU KNOW, UH, OVERHEAD EXPENSES AND THEN DISTRIBUTE THE REST.

IN THOSE CASES, UM, THOSE RESTAURANTS WOULD NOT BE ELIGIBLE TO TAKE THE TIP CREDIT, AND THEY WOULD HAVE TO PAY THE STAFF THE FULL MINIMUM WAGE.

AND JOE, IS THERE ANYTHING WE CAN DO ABOUT INSTANCES LIKE THAT, OR DOES THAT JUST KIND OF FALL WITHIN FEDERAL LAW, AND WE HOPE THAT THEY'RE BEING GOOD WELL, I- CITIZENS? I THINK, I MEAN, OF COURSE, WE'RE LOOKING AT IT FROM THE STANDPOINT OF TAXABILITY HERE, BUT IF IT'S, IF IT'S LABELED AS A SERVICE CHARGE, I BELIEVE IT'S TAXABLE. NOW, IN, IF IT'S LABELED AS A SERVICE CHARGE, MOST, A LOT OF PEOPLE WILL ASSUME THAT'S A TIP, BUT THERE, WE FOUND RESTAURANTS THAT KEEP THE ENTIRE SERVICE CHARGE. WE FOUND RESTAURANTS THAT KEEP A PART OF IT, UH, AND WE, AND THERE ARE MAYBE RESTAURANTS THAT GIVE IT ALL TO THEM, BUT SO THE LABELING REALLY NEEDS TO BE CLEARER, I THINK, I MEAN, TO- SO YOU, YOUR TEAM HAS THE ABILITY IN YOUR AUDITS TO HAVE THAT LEVEL OF GRANULARITY AND HAVE ENFORCEMENT INTO THAT? WELL, WE HAVE, WE ENFORCE, YOU KNOW, WHAT WE GET, AND, AND, AND, AND WE HAVE TO INTERPRET, YOU KNOW, THE, THE. YEAH.

WHAT'S ON THESE BILLS, BUT AS FAR AS THE ABILITY OF THE CITY TO MANDATE THAT THEY, I THINK I'D, I'D HAVE TO, YOU KNOW, DEFER TO THE CITY ATTORNEY ON WHATEVER THE CITY'S AUTHORITY IS, BUT I THINK IT'S A REAL PROBLEM, AND IT'S A REAL CONSUMER PROBLEM TOO, BECAUSE, I MEAN, THERE ARE, I'M SURE THERE ARE STAFF BEING SHORTED BECAUSE PEOPLE ASSUME THE 20% SERVICE CHARGE IS GOING TO THE STAFF, AND MANY TIMES IT ISN'T, AND SOMETIMES NONE OF IT IS.

CHAIR, IF I MAY, I THINK THERE'S A COUPLE OF ISSUES ARE HERE TO HELP CLARIFY A BIT. I THINK ONE OF THE ISSUES, BECAUSE I'VE WORKED A BIT WITH, UM, JOE'S OFFICE ON THIS ISSUE, IS THE TAXABILITY CONCEPT, WHICH IS RIGHT NOW THE 2% UM, FOOD AND BEVERAGE RESORT TAX, UH, YOU KNOW, THE, THE PART OF THE DISCUSSION IS SHOULD THAT 2% BE APPLIED TO THE 20% SERVICE CHARGE? BECAUSE, AS HE'S STATING, IF IT'S ALL TIP, THEN IT'S NOT, WOULD NOT BE SUBJECT TO IT. BUT THE PROBLEM IS WE HAVE SOME THAT ARE, IT'S ALL OVER THE PLACE. SO I THINK THAT THE ISSUE, I THINK WHAT THE ASK FOR THE OIG'S OFFICE IS, MAYBE AS PART OF THIS TO, OR TO PIGGYBACK ON IT, BECAUSE THEY'RE PROBABLY TWO DIFFERENT SECTIONS OF THE CODE, WOULD BE TO CLARIFY, IS THAT 2% APPLIED TO, IF THERE IS A SERVICE CHARGE, NOT A GRATUITY, IF IT SAYS GRATUITY, IT'S NOT, BUT IF IT SAYS SERVICE CHARGE, WHETHER OR NOT IT WOULD BE 2%.

SO MAYBE WHEN THIS ITEM COMES OUT, IT'S, IT'S PERHAPS MAYBE 2 ORDINANCES, TO BE QUITE HONEST, UH, OR, OR 2 DIFFERENT SECTIONS, IS PERHAPS TO LOOK AT THE LANGUAGE ABOUT THE BRIGHT VISIBILITY, UH, THE LANGUAGE THAT COMMISSIONER FERNANDEZ HAD, HAD BROUGHT FORWARD, MAYBE THAT ALL COULD BE INCORPORATED, AND WITH OIG RECOMMENDATIONS ON THE TAXABILITY OF THAT.

MAYBE THAT'S THE MOTION THAT CAN COME OUT, AND IT'S ALL THAT ALL-ENCOMPASSING, AND THEN MAYBE OIG AND STAFF CAN WORK TOGETHER WITH THE CITY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE, AND I SEE RICK'S WANTING TO CHIME IN, TO COME BACK WITH ONE OR MORE ORDINANCES TO, TO CLARIFY THESE ISSUES, BUT.

SO THAT, THAT JUST KIND OF THREW ME THROUGH A LOOP HERE. SO IF A RESTAURANT CHARGES A SERVICE CHARGE 20%, WHICH IN MY MIND, I USE THAT INTERCHANGEABLY WITH GRATUITY.

MM-HMM.

THEY ARE TAXED ON THAT, BUT IF

[00:50:01]

THEY DON'T CHARGE IT AND I LEAVE A 20% TIP, THAT'S NOT TAXED? THE, THE TIPS ARE NOT TAXED.

THE GRATUITIES ARE, ARE, ARE, ARE NOT.

THE PROBLEM THAT THE OIG'S OFFICE IS HAVING DURING, AND NOT TO SPEAK FOR HIM, BUT TO, BECAUSE I, I GET INVOLVED IN THIS AS A SPECIAL MAGISTRATE WHEN THERE'S AN APPEAL, IS THAT WE'RE, IS THE ENTITIES IN WHICH THEY SAY, UM, WELL, WE'RE, WE'RE, WE'RE KEEPING MONEY FOR A CREDIT CARD FEE, AND WE'RE KEEPING MONEY FOR THIS, AND THEN WE START SPLITTING HAIRS, WHICH IS WHERE I THINK THE DIFFICULTY IN HIS AUDITS ARE. UM, IF IT'S ALL GRATUITY, IT'S, IT'S, YOU KNOW, IT'S NOT AN ISSUE. UH, SO IF THEY SAY THE SERVICE CHARGE 20%, IT ALL GOES, IT'S GRATUITY, NOT AN ISSUE. THE ISSUE IS WHERE IT'S SPLIT, UH, OR IF IT'S FULLY RETAINED.

SO, SO CLEAR, I THINK WHAT THE OAG IS LOOKING FOR IS CLARITY ON THAT.

BUT IF I MAY, THROUGH THE CHAIR, UM, I THINK JOE IS MORE FAMILIAR THAN I AM POTENTIALLY ON THIS, BUT I BELIEVE THAT WHAT THE STATE LOOKS AT, WHICH IS THE SAME THING THAT WE LOOK AT FOR PURPOSES OF RESORT TAX, IS WHETHER IT'S VOLUNTARY OR NOT. UM, I DON'T THINK IF IT'S AN AUTOMATIC GRATUITY, IT DOESN'T BECOME, IT IT'S STILL SUBJECT TO SALES TAX, I BELIEVE, IF IT'S, IF IT'S AUTOMATIC, IT IT IT TURNS ON WHETHER IT'S VOLUNTARY OR NOT. BUT JOE, I KNOW THAT YOU'VE LOOKED AT THIS.

I I THINK THE GRATUITY IS NOT TAXABLE. THAT'S THAT'S OUR OUR POSITION, BUT THE PROBLEM IS, YOU KNOW, IF IT'S LABELED AS A SERVICE CHARGE, WHAT IS IT? IS IT A GRATUITY, OR IS, YOU KNOW, IS IT NOT A GRATUITY? AND AS AND THE, AND THE STATE HAS TAKEN THE POSITION THEY'RE ALL OVER THAT.

THAT IF ANY PORTION OF IT GOES TO THE, TO THE RESTAURANT, ALL OF IT IS TAXABLE.

THAT'S THE LAW IS THAT IF, IF, IF THE RESTAURANT IS KEEPING ANY OF IT, THEN IT'S ALL TAXABLE.

RIGHT.

UH.

AND THAT'S WHERE, IF I MAY, MR. CHAIR, I THINK, YOU KNOW, WHEN IT COMES TO TIP, IT'S VERY CLEAR HOW TIP CAN BE ADMINISTERED, AND THAT'S CLEARLY DEFINED BY THE FEDERAL LAW. AND I JUST FEEL LIKE MAYBE I'M SIMPLIFYING THIS TOO MUCH, BUT, YOU KNOW, TIP, GRATUITY, WHICHEVER WAY YOU WANT TO CALL IT, CLEARLY THE S- UH, INCOME TA- OR TAX LAWS DICTATE HOW THAT CAN BE USED.

BUT SEPARATELY IS ANY OTHER TYPE OF CHARGE THAT'S IMPOSED THERE, WHETHER IT BE CALLED A SERVICE CHARGE OR AN OPERATIONS CHARGE OR WHATEVER OTHER TYPE OF CHARGE THAT CREATES THE AMBIGUITY THAT IS NOT CLEAR TO PEOPLE, WHETHER IT'S A TIP, WHETHER IT GOES TO THE SERVER OR TO BACK OF HOUSE, OR WHETHER IT'S USED TO PAY FOR, I DON'T KNOW, DISHES THAT ARE BROKEN AND REPLACE DISHES THAT ARE BROKEN.

AND THAT'S WHERE I THINK, YOU KNOW, HAVING THAT CLARITY, THAT CLARITY AND GIVING, REQUIRING, REQUIRING, UH, FOR RESTAURANTS THAT CHOOSE TO PUT A SERVICE CHARGE OR AN OPERATIONS CHARGE ON THEIR BILL, REQUIRING THEM TO CHOOSE ONE OF THESE 3 OPTIONS FROM IT. UM, BUT I MIGHT NOT BE UNDERSTANDING IT RIGHT, SO BECAUSE I'VE JUST COME TO REALIZE OVER TIME THAT ALL OF THESE RESTAURANT ISSUES ARE EXTREMELY COMPLICATED AND WELL OVER MY, UM, MY 6,000 DOLLAR PAY GRADE.

MANY THINGS ARE OVER MINE, UH, SO DON'T FEEL BAD. UH, COMMISSIONER MATTEO-SALINAS, THEN I'VE PROMISED CITY STAFF, UH, WE- WE'LL LEAVE IT TO YOU, THAT PROBABLY KNOWS MORE ABOUT THIS THAN ALL OF US UP HERE, UH, SPEAKING IN CIRCLES.

UM, YEAH, THIS IS A VERY, VERY COMPLICATED ISSUE, AND I JUST HAVE A COUPLE QUESTIONS THAT I'D LIKE TO CLARIFY.

MISTER ATTORNEY, SO YOU HAD STATED WHEN COMMISSIONER DOMINGUEZ ASKED IF WE, IF THE RESTAURANT CAN CHARGE THE 20% OPERATIONS CHARGE, AND YOU HAD STATED THAT WE CAN'T REGULATE WHAT A RESTAURANT CHARGES? THAT IS CORRECT.

SO, ESSENTIALLY, THEY CAN PUT ON THE RECEIPT, THEY CAN PUT A 20% CHARGE FOR THEIR RENT, OR THEY CAN PUT A 5% CHARGE.

TODAY'S TUESDAY, AND IT'S 5% EXTRA TODAY, AND THEY'RE, AND WE CAN'T REGULATE THAT.

THAT'S INDISPUTABLE? WE ARE LARGELY PREEMPTED BY THE STATE ON, ON RESTAURANT, ON HOTELS AND RESTAURANTS.

EVEN IF THEY CHARGE SOMETHING THAT YOU DIDN'T PURCHASE.

WELL, IF, I DON'T UNDERSTAND THE QUESTION. WHAT DO YOU MEAN? IF, IF YOU BUY FOOD AND THEY'RE CHARGING AN A PERCENTAGE OVER AND ABOVE THE COST OF THE MENU ITEM, THAT, THAT IS ALLOWED.

BUT IF THEY ADD A CHARGE ON THERE JUST BECAUSE THEY WANT TO FOR ANYTHING THAT YOU DIDN'T KNOW WAS GOING TO BE ON YOUR BILL, WE CAN'T REGULATE THAT? WELL, WHAT THE NEW STATE LAW DOES IS THAT IF THEY'RE GOING TO, IF THE RESTAURANT IS GOING TO CHARGE AN OPERATIONS CHARGE, WHICH INCLUDES THOSE RENT.

RANDOM CHARGES THAT YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT, I DON'T THINK THEY'RE GOING TO LABEL IT RENT, THEY'RE GOING TO LABEL IT SERVICE CHARGE, OPERATIONS CHARGE, UM, THEN THEY HAVE TO DISCLOSE THAT ON THEIR MENUS, ON THE BILL, UM, IF THEY HAVE A WEBSITE, ON THEIR WEBSITE, THEY HAVE TO DISCLOSE UNDER THE STATE LAW. UM, AND IF THAT, IF THAT SERVICE CHARGE INCLUDES A GRATUITY, THAT ALSO HAS TO BE SEPARATELY STATED.

BUT, BUT WE CAN'T REGULATE SOMETHING, BECAUSE I, THIS OPERATIONS, IF A SERVICE, WHENEVER THERE'S A SERVICE CHARGE, EVERYONE ASSUMES THAT'S A TIP.

THAT'S WHAT IT'S CALLED, SO NO ONE'S SURPRISED BY THAT, BUT HAVING AN OPERATIONS CHARGE OR A CHARGE

[00:55:01]

FOR SOMETHING THAT YOU DIDN'T EXPECT TO HAVE. SO YOU'RE SAYING AS LONG AS IT'S DISCLOSED ON THEIR MENU AND WEBSITE, THEY CAN CHARGE ANY TYPE OF CHARGE IN ADDITION TO WHAT YOU PURCHASE.

YES, AND, AND, AND JUST TO BE CLEAR, I'M USING THE TERM OPERATIONS CHARGE BECAUSE THAT IS THE TERM USED IN THE STATUTE, BUT MOST RESTAURANTS CALL IT A SERVICE CHARGE. I DON'T, I DON'T THINK I'VE BEEN ANY REST- TO ANY RESTAURANT THAT SAYS OPERATIONS CHARGE, BUT THAT'S JUST THE DEFINED TERM THAT'S USED IN THE STATUTE, WHICH INCLUDES SERVICE CHARGES AND INCLUDES AUTOMATIC TIPS, ET CETERA.

SO, AND THE SERVICE CHARGE, WHAT WE'RE SAYING TODAY IS THAT IF IT'S, IF IT'S, IF IT'S WRITTEN ON THE RECEIPT AS A SERVICE CHARGE, THE WHOLE PERCENTAGE IS TAXABLE FOR RESORT TAXES.

THAT'S WHAT, YES, THAT'S, THAT'S WHAT WE CONSIDER.

ON THE OTHER HAND, YOU KNOW, IF IN FACT WE FIND OUT THAT ALL OF IT IS GOING TO THE, TO A SERVER, THEN WE WOULDN'T CONSIDER THAT TO BE TAXABLE. BUT THE PROBLEM IS THEY'RE CALLING SERVICE CHARGE, IT, IT MAY REPRESENT ANYTHING. IT MAY REPRESENT A GRATUITY, MAY REPRESENT MONEY GOES STRAIGHT TO THE, UH, YOU KNOW, TO THE, UH, TO THE BUSINESS, OR THERE MAY BE SOME, YOU KNOW, DIVISION, UH, SOME OF IT GOES AND SOME OF IT DOESN'T, BUT THERE'S NO CLARITY.

MM-HMM.

AND THE CONSUMER IS VERY CONFUSED ABOUT THAT.

AND WE CAN'T REGULATE WHERE THAT SERVICE CHARGE MONEY GOES, RIGHT? THAT RICK? NO, WE CANNOT.

BECAUSE UNFORTUNATELY, WHAT HAPPENS IF I SEE A 20% SERVICE CHARGE, I ASSUME THAT'S 20% GOING TO THE STAFF. SO WHAT I'M HEARING TODAY IS, UH, 10% COULD GO TO THE RESTAURANT, AND IT'S ONLY 10% THAT GETS DISTRIBUTED TO THE STAFF.

MM-HMM.

IT'S, THAT'S UNFORTUNATE. LET ME HAND IT TO CITY STAFF.

SURE. GOOD MORNING, UH, CHAIR AND COMMITTEE. UH, EDGAR ESTRADA, ASSISTANT CO-COMPLIANCE. UM, AS HAS BEEN DISCUSSED, THE STATE LAW, UH, DID GO INTO EFFECT JULY 1ST, UH, OF THIS YEAR. UH, IT, IT ALREADY REQUIRES RESTAURANTS TO ITEMIZE ANY ADDITIONAL CHARGES, WHETHER IT'S AUTOMATIC GRATUITIES, UH, CREDIT CARD SURCHARGES, SO THOSE HAVE TO BE SPECIFIED ON THE RECEIPT. UM, IT DOES NOT PROHIBIT US FROM REQUIRING ANYTHING ABOVE AND BEYOND, UH, FOR EXAMPLE, MORE PROMINENCE ON ON THE RECEIPTS. SO THAT IS SOMETHING THAT WE ARE ABLE TO DO. UH, NOW, AS FAR AS POINT OF SALE SYSTEMS, MOST RESTAURANTS ARE DIGITAL IN THAT SENSE, UH, SO THEY COULD EASILY, UH, PROGRAM THE POS SYSTEMS TO INCLUDE, UH, SOME STANDARD LANGUAGE, UH, WHICH WE DID PROVIDE IN THE MEMO, UH, SOMETHING KIND OF SHORT BECAUSE THE RECEIPTS ALSO DON'T HAVE TOO MUCH ROOM, UH, BUT FOR THOSE RESTAURANTS THAT DON'T HAVE ANY DIGITAL, UH, RECEIPTS OR, OR MAYBE PAPER RECEIPTS, THEY CAN INVEST IN, IN A, IN A STAMP. SO IT, IT WOULDN'T, UH, BE ANYTHING TOO BURDENSOME, UH, FINANCIALLY FOR THE RESTAURANT.

YEAH, SO EVEN WITH THE STATE LAW, I'D LIKE TO THINK THAT OUR RESTAURANTS, UH, HAVEN'T BEEN THAT PREDATORY WHERE THEY'LL ACTUALLY CONCEAL OR HIDE THAT SERVICE CHARGE IS ADDED. SO I THINK THE INTENT OF THIS WAS TO GO ABOVE AND BEYOND AND REALLY JUST BRING THE FURTHER ATTENTION. SO, TO YOUR POINT, JUST BECAUSE THE STATE LAW REQUIRES, I HAVE A FEELING 90% OF 99% OF THE TIME THAT'S ALREADY HAPPENING, THE SPIRIT OF THIS IS TO GO ABOVE AND BEYOND, BRING THAT TO THE ATTENTION. SO MAYBE WE COULD ASK CITY STAFF TO COME BACK WITH A FEW OPTIONS WHEN THIS GOES TO, UH, FULL COMMISSION OF WHAT THAT FURTHER DISCLOSURE WILL BE. I- I'D LIKE IF YOU COULD INCORPORATE COMMISSIONER FERNANDEZ'S, UH, RECOMMENDATIONS, BUT THEN LET'S ALSO HAVE, WHETHER IT BE A RED STAMP AT THE TOP OR THE BOTTOM OF THE BILL THAT SAYS, YOU KNOW, GOD, I DON'T EVEN KNOW WHAT IS THE SERVICE CHARGE, GRATUITY ALREADY INCLUDED. I, I TODAY, UH, TALK ABOUT OPENING PANDORA'S BOX, UM, BUT SOME SORT OF ABOVE AND BEYOND DISCLOSURE THAT, UH, JUST ENHANCES CONSUMER AWARENESS. AND I STILL DON'T THINK WE'RE GOING TO GET TO THE CONSUMER CONFUSION, BECAUSE EVEN THOUGH IT'S BEEN EXPLAINED BY OUR CITY ATTORNEY STAFF AND OUR IG, I THINK THERE'S STILL A GREAT DEAL OF AMBIGUITY, UH, WHICH IS UNFORTUNATE.

SURE, AND THROUGH THE CHAIR, UM, BECAUSE THE THE STATE LAW CAME INTO EFFECT AFTER COMMISSIONER FERNANDEZ HAD WORKED ON THOSE THREE OPTIONS, WE WILL WORK WITH WITH THE CODE, UM, ENFORCEMENT OFFICE AND ANYBODY ELSE ON STAFF TO TWEAK THE LANGUAGE SO THAT IT IS, IS MORE CONSISTENT.

AND IF I, AND IF I MAY SHARE, I THINK, SO I, I DRAFTED A BIT FROM, UH, THE MEMO FROM, FROM CODE HERE. I'M GOING TO GO THROUGH IT, AND I ADDING, UH, YOU KNOW, CONCEPTS FROM COMMISSIONER FERNANDEZ PRESENTED, AND PERHAPS ALSO SOME CLARIFYING LANGUAGE THAT THE OIG MAY WANT TO HAVE ON THE, ON THE TAX THING THAT WE CAN ALL ENCOMPASS IT. SO ME, I'M GOING TO TRY TO READ THROUGH THIS, BUT I THINK IT, IT GETS EVERYTHING TO THE SPIRIT OF WHAT YOU WERE SPEAKING TO.

SO I THINK IT'S A RETURN TO COMMISSION WITH A FAVORABLE RECOMMENDATION PREPARED ORDINANCE TO, UH, TO HAVE A CITY REQUIREMENT THAT REQUIRES ALL FOOD SERVICE ESTABLISHMENTS TO PLACE A BRIGHT, UH, HIGHLY VISIBLE STAMP AT THE TOP OF A CUSTOMER'S RECEIPTS WHENEVER GRATUITY SERVICE CHARGES OR SIMILAR AUTOMATIC FEES ARE INCLUDED IN THE TOTAL BILL, AND WILL INCLUDE CONCEPTS PRESENTED BY COMMISSIONER FERNANDEZ AND ANY CLARIFYING RECOMMENDATIONS FROM THE OIG. I THINK THAT WOULD BE

[01:00:02]

THE MOTION.

AND JOE, IF THERE'S FURTHER THINGS THAT WE CAN DO ABOUT THIS WHOLE ENTIRE, YOU KNOW, UH, THING THAT WE DISCUSSED HERE TODAY, HAPPY TO WORK WITH YOUR OFFICE. UH, AS YOU'VE SEEN FROM THIS COMMISSION, WE WANT TO HELP OUR SMALL BUSINESSES, BUT WE ALSO WANT TO HELP OUR, OUR STAFF THAT'S WORKING AT THESE SMALL BUSINESSES, AND PERHAPS THAT'S NOT ALWAYS 100% ALIGNED. UM, WE WANT TO BE SURE THAT SOME OF THESE BUSINESSES ALSO AREN'T TAKING ADVANTAGE OF, UH, THE STAFF THAT'S WORKING THERE AS WELL.

SO, THANK YOU ALL FOR YOUR WORK ON THIS.

SO, SO WHO WILL MAKE THAT MOTION? I'LL MAKE IT.

I'LL SECOND.

ALL IN FAVOR? AYE.

ALL RIGHT. SHOWING IT PASSED 3-0. THANK YOU. DO WE STILL HAVE COMMISSIONER BHATT AS A PANELIST IF WE WANT AN UPDATE ON OB4? I THINK THIS SHOULD BE KIND OF TAKEN CARE OF, GIVEN THE NEW, UH, PARKING FACILITY THAT CAME ONLINE, BUT I DON'T WANT TO, UH, SPEAK FOR HER. DO WE HAVE COMMISSIONER BHATT? BENEFITS.

SHE'S A PANELIST, OKAY.

[OB 4. DISCUSS THE POSSIBILITY OF THE CITY ENTERING INTO ONE OR MORE AGREEMENTS WITH PRIVATE PARKING FACILITY OPERATORS IN NORTH BEACH IN ORDER TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF AVAILABLE PARKING SPACES FOR NORTH BEACH RESIDENTS.]

SOMEBODY READ IN OB4? SO WE'LL BRING UP OB4. OB4, DISCUSS THE POSSIBILITY OF THE CITY ENTERING INTO ONE OR MORE AGREEMENTS WITH PRIVATE PARKING FACILITY OPERATORS IN NORTH BEACH IN ORDER TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF AVAILABLE PARKING SPACES FOR NORTH BEACH RESIDENTS. OB4.

WILL, PLEASE.

WILL MCDONALD, DIRECTOR OF PARKING. SO, UM, THE PARKING DEPARTMENT IS GOING TO CONTINUE TO EXHAUST ALL POSSIBILITIES, UM, WITH THIS ITEM.

OBVIOUSLY, WHEN WE ARE LOOKING AT NORTH BEACH, UM, WITH CONTINUED EXPANSION THAT IS OCCURRING FOR ANYBODY THAT'S DRIVEN NEAR HAWTHORNE, INDIAN CREEK, UM, COLLINS. UM, OUR CHALLENGE IS RIGHT NOW THERE'S NOT A LOT OF PRIVATE OPERATORS IN THE MARKET, UM, UH, WITH WITH THE CURRENT INFRASTRUCTURE THAT IS UP THERE. OBVIOUSLY, THE DEAUVILLE WAS, UH, A, A GREAT FIND FOR THE CITY, AND OBVIOUSLY WHEN THAT BEACH WALK IS GOING TO BE TAKEN, UH, THAT IS GOING TO BENEFIT THE COMMUNITY. WE ARE STILL EVALUATING, AS I PLACED ON THE ITEM, SOME ITEMS THAT WE THINK WILL HAVE A, A GREAT EFFECT. UH, THE, THE BANDSHELL ONE-WAY VALET PILOT, I'LL ADMIT, DURING FIFA, UH, BECAUSE OF THE DEAUVILLE BEING OPEN AND WE HAD A SHUTTLE PROGRAM, WE THOUGHT THAT THE SPACES NEAREST TO THE BANDSHELL WERE GOING TO BE BETTER USED FOR PARKING AND SHUTTLE TRANSPORTATION TO AND FROM THE DOVILLE. UM, THE, THE WEST LOTS RIGHT NOW, OBVIOUSLY WE'RE, YOU KNOW, STAYING AWAY. WE'RE NOT GOING TO BRING ANYTHING TO THE COMMISSION. AND WHEN THE 72ND, IF AND WHEN THE 72ND STREET PROJECT GOES INTO EFFECT, WE ARE GOING TO WORK, YOU KNOW, TRYING TO BE, UH, WE ARE GOING TO WORK WITH OUR TRANSPORTATION PARTNERS TO CREATE A TROLLEY OR SHUTTLE LOOP BETWEEN THE DEAUVILLE AND THE WEST LOTS THAT ARE ALREADY PARKING LOTS IN THE NORTHERN AREA THAT ARE UNDERUTILIZED, TO CREATE A TIGHT TRANSPORTATION LOOP.

UM, AND THEN WE ARE ALSO, UM, OPEN TO RECEIVING, UM, I'LL SAY THERE, WE'RE OPEN TO LOOKING AT OTHER OPPORTUNITIES TO POSSIBLY HAVE, UH, UH, P3 TYPE, UH, PARTNERSHIPS WITHIN OUR PARKING LOTS AND OPEN TO ANYONE BRINGING ANY IDEAS TO US TO BUILD ADDITIONAL INFRASTRUCTURE.

THROUGH THE CHAIR, IF I MAY? PLEASE.

UH, WILL, THANK YOU FOR THE UPDATE. THIS HAS BEEN SOMETHING THAT, UM, WE'VE BEEN BANGING OUR HEADS AGAINST, UH, SINCE I WAS ELECTED. THERE ARE A COUPLE OF PRIVATELY OWNED LOTS, UM, ONE ON, UM, BAY DRIVE AND BREAST ESPLANADE THAT ARE MINIMALLY USE- U- UH, MINIMALLY USED. I THINK THERE ARE 14 CARS IN THERE AT ANY GIVEN TIME, AND THEY HAVE ROOM FOR PROBABLY ANOTHER 20 TO 30 MORE. THERE IS, UM, SIGNIFICANT OVERDEVELOPMENT OF PARKING SPACES THAT ARE UNDERUTILIZED AT 72ND STREET, UM, AT THE 72 PARK, UH, BUILDING. HAVE WE REACHED OUT RECENTLY, UM, TO THE INDIVIDUAL OWNERS OF THOSE LOTS? THE FIRST ONE IS A SMALL SURFACE LOT IN FRONT OF A MULTI-FAMILY, UM, SINGLE STORY UNIT. UM, AND I KNOW 3 YEARS AGO THE OWNER WAS RETICENT AND CONCERNED ABOUT INSURANCE ISSUES. I CAN'T SPEAK TO, UM, THE CONCERNS THAT THE FOLKS AT 72 PARK MIGHT HAVE, BUT IT SURE WOULD GO A LONG WAY TO, UM, IMPROVING THEIR, UM, PERCEPTION AMONG THE NORTH BEACH COMMUNITY. HAVE WE REVISITED ANY CONVERSATIONS WITH THOSE TWO AND ANY OTHERS THAT I MIGHT NOT KNOW ABOUT? UM, SO COMMISSIONER, TO ADDRESS THE PARKING LOT, IF, UH, WE COULD OFFLINE, UH, GET THAT ADDRESSED BECAUSE WE

[01:05:01]

DEFINITELY HAVEN'T REACHED OUT TO THEM. UM, 72 PARK, WE INITIALLY STARTED OUR CONVERSATIONS WITH 72 PARK WITH A KIND OF APPROACH. WE ADDRESSED THEM FIRST ON TEMPORARY S- UH, STORAGE FOR THE ONE-WAY, UH, VALET FOR THE BANDSHELL. UM, WE WERE LOOKING AT WHERE THAT WOULD SET UP.

UH, THEY WERE OPEN TO THAT WHEN WE TALKED ABOUT, UH, WHEN WE ADDRESSED THE, HEY, WHAT IF WE TALKED ABOUT JUST TAKING OVER THE OPERATIONS OF THE GARAGE, UH, THERE WAS LESS RECEPTION TO THAT, UH, SIMPLY BECAUSE I- I THINK THERE'S SOME CONCERN ABOUT, UH, THE OCCUPANCY, OCCUPANTS OF THAT PARTICULAR BUILDING NOW OPENING IT UP TO PUBLIC PARKING, AND I THINK THERE'S THIS MISCONCEPTION THAT PUBLIC PARKING, ESPECIALLY BEACH-GOING PUBLIC PARKING, YOU KNOW, MIGHT INCLUDE INEBRIATED INDIVIDUALS, INDIVIDUALS WHO CARE, YOU KNOW, DON'T CARE ABOUT GARAGES AS MUCH, AND SO YOU, THERE'S SOME PROTECTION OVER WHAT THEY CONSIDER A PRISTINE FACILITY. WE WILL CONTINUE THOSE CONVERSATIONS AND BE AGGRESSIVE IN OUR APPROACH. I KNOW THAT THEY HAVE ATTEMPTED TO OPERATE IT MUCH MORE PUBLICLY AS A LOT, AS, UH, WE'VE RECEIVED SOME PHOTOS OF THEIR SIGNS BEING OUT IN THE RIGHT OF WAY. UM, BUT WE WILL CONTINUE TO HAVE THOSE CONVERSATIONS, UH, BUT IF WE COULD GET THAT ADDRESSED FROM YOU OR YOUR TEAM MEMBERS, UH, FOR THE FLAT LOT. THERE HAVE BEEN A FEW OTHER FLAT LOTS, UH, THAT WE HAVE, UH, DISCUSSED THERE. THE FLAT LOT BEHIND THE CVS, WHICH I KNOW, UH, REMAINS RELATIVELY EMPTY THE MAJORITY OF THE TIME. UH, UNFORTUNATELY, YOU RUN INTO A SITUATION WITH SOME OF THESE PRIVATE LOTS WHERE IT'S NOT THEIR MAIN BUSINESS OR THEY'RE LEAVING IT EMPTY TO DEVELOP IT VERY SOON, AND NOBODY WANTS TO TAKE ON THE LIABILITY ASPECT, AND WE AS A CITY CAN'T INDEMNIFY THEM, AND SO IT GETS INTO HOW MUCH IS IT WORTH FOR TO COVER LIABILITY INSURANCE.

YOU KNOW, IT IT GETS INTO A VERY TOUGH SITUATION.

WILL, IF I COULD, UM, FOLLOW UP ON A COUPLE THINGS.

YES.

ON THE 72 PARK LOT, WHAT ABOUT THE IDEA OF JUST DOING IT, UM, MAKING IT AN OVERNIGHT LOT, SO AL- ALLAYING THE CONCERNS OF, UM, CARELESS BEACHGOERS, PERHAPS, WHICH, YOU KNOW, I THINK IS UNFOUNDED IN THIS PARTICULAR AREA, BUT WHATEVER. UM, BUT, YOU KNOW, THE, THE CONCERN IS THE NIGHTTIME EVENTS, PEOPLE GOING TO THE BANDSHELL FOR EVENTS WHEN THE BYRON CARLISLE GETS BUILT, UM, MAKING SURE THAT THAT'S ACCESSIBLE, UM, AND FOR RESIDENTS WHO ARE JUST SCRAMBLING TRYING TO FIND PARKING, UM, MAYBE THAT'S A WIN FOR EVERYBODY. UM, THE OTHER THING IS THE, UM... UH, WHAT WAS THE SECOND POINT? WHAT WAS YOUR LAST POINT, WILL? I'M SORRY.

SO WHEN YOU, UH, YOU KNOW, A LOT OF TIMES.

OH, THE 74TH, 74TH, UM, UH, STREET LOT.

YEP.

SO 7400 COLLINS IS BEING REDEVELOPED AS A LIB LOCAL PROJECT, WHICH IS DELIGHTFUL.

INSTEAD OF HAVING A ONE-STORY BUILDING ON THAT SPOT, WE ARE NOW GOING TO HAVE AN 11-STORY BUILDING GOING ON TO ONE OF THE BUSIEST AND NARROWEST STRETCHES OF COLLINS. CAN YOU WORK WITH, UM, DEBBIE TACKETT IN PLANNING AND SEE WHAT, IF ANY, PLANS EXIST FOR THAT LOT NOW, AND IF IT'S BEING INCORPORATED INTO THEIR BUILDING PLAN? I DON'T KNOW IF IT'S THE SAME OWNER, UM, BUT CAN WE WRAP THAT CONVERSATION INTO THIS AS WELL? BECAUSE THAT'S GOING TO BECOME A REAL PROBLEM.

YES, ABSOLUTELY.

OKAY, THANK YOU.

MY PLEASURE.

MR. CFO, YOU WANT TO TAKE A STAB AT THIS? UH, I'M NOT SURE THAT THERE'S A, A MOTION. I THINK THIS WAS REALLY JUST A DISCUSSION ITEM FOR, FOR AN UPDATE, BUT- YEAH, I WOULD BE, IF, IF, IF THE COMMITTEE ALLOWS, UM, WE'RE GOING TO CONTINUE OUR EFFORTS, AND SO IF THIS, IF THIS STAYS HERE, UM, TO GIVE US AN OPPORTUNITY OR AN AVENUE TO COME BACK TO DISCUSS IT IN THE NEXT, YOU KNOW, 30, 60, 90 DAYS. YOU KNOW, ONE OF THE THINGS THAT, SOME IDEAS OF MAYBE GOING TO 72 PARK AND NOT TO ASKING FOR OPERATION OF THE GARAGE, BUT, UM, FOR A PARTICULAR GUARANTEE, ENSURING THAT THEY OFFER A THE RESIDENT DISCOUNT TO REGISTERED RESIDENTS LIKE WE DO. THERE'S SOME TECHNOLOGY ASPECTS WE'D HAVE TO WORK THROUGH, BUT THAT COULD ALSO BE ANOTHER ALTERNATE, UH, TO JUST SAY, HEY, NOT EVERYBODY, BUT THE, YOU KNOW, REGISTERED RESIDENTS WILL GET THE REGISTERED RESIDENT DISCOUNT.

AND HOW IS THE UTILIZATION OF THE NEW NORTH BEACH PARKING GARAGE? SO I, I CAN'T SPEAK. IT IS A PRIVATE FACILITY. UM, I KNOW THAT I'VE DRIVEN UP INSIDE THERE PROBABLY, I DON'T KNOW, UM, ONCE EVERY 2 OR 3 WEEKS JUST TO GET A BETTER UNDERSTANDING. I FEEL IT'S ALWAYS EMPTY WHEN I DRIVE UP INSIDE THE GARAGE, UM, BUT I, BUT I CAN'T SPEAK BECAUSE WE DON'T HAVE ACCESS.

SO THAT'S WHAT I'VE HEARD AS WELL, AND I DON'T WANT TO USE JUST ANECDOTAL FEEDBACK LIKE MINE AND YOURS, BUT LET'S KEEP AN EYE ON THAT, UM, BECAUSE, UH, YOU KNOW, WHILE WE ALL HEAR ABOUT THE PARKING NEEDS UP THERE, LET LET'S BE SURE THAT WE'RE

[01:10:01]

MONITORING, UH, FACTUAL, YOU KNOW, EVIDENCE AND THINGS LIKE THAT, AND, YOU KNOW, IF THERE'S DIFFERENT TWEAKS THAT NEED TO HAPPEN TO BE SURE THAT THAT GETS THE UTILIZATION THAT I THINK WE ALL THINK IT SHOULD, UM, BUT IF IT DOESN'T, THEN, YOU KNOW, WE CAN'T BE DOGMATIC, AND WE HAVE TO COME BACK TO THE DRAWING BOARD.

I THINK, I THINK WITH THAT PARTICULAR FACILITY, THERE'S, THERE'S PROBABLY 2 STRIKES AGAINST IT. ONE, UH, NOBODY KNOWS THAT IT'S A PUBLIC PARKING GARAGE, UH, BECAUSE IT DOESN'T REALLY FACE ITSELF LIKE THAT, AND TO BE HONEST WITH YOU, THAT'S NOT PART OF PROBABLY THE INITIAL BUSINESS MODEL. AND TWO, AT THE 4 DOLLARS AN HOUR RATE, WHERE IN NORTH BEACH EVERYBODY IS GENERALLY ACCUSTOMED TO THE 1 DOLLAR AN HOUR NO MATTER WHAT, UM, THERE'S PROBABLY LIKE, I WILL DO ANYTHING. I CAME TO NORTH BEACH NOT TO PAY 4 DOLLARS AN HOUR LIKE WE DO IN SOUTH BEACH.

AND THROUGH THE CHAIR, IF I MAY, UM, I ALSO WANT TO ADD THAT IT'S UNDERUTILIZED RIGHT NOW, BUT I THINK, UM, WHEN THE 72ND STREET COMPLEX STARTS, UM, CONSTRUCTION AND THOSE 350 SPOTS GO AWAY, UM, IT WILL BECOME VERY HIGHLY UTILIZED.

SIMILARLY, THERE'S A BIG CONSTRUCTION PROJECT SCHEDULED FOR THE BLOCKS JUST NORTH OF THAT PARKING GARAGE, UM, WHERE THERE IS CURRENTLY RESIDENT PARKING IN ZONE 26, AND AGAIN, UH, ZONE 26 RESIDENTS CAN PARK IN THE GARAGE FOR FREE. ONCE THAT PARKING GOES OFFLINE, UM, THE DOVILLE GARAGE WILL DEFINITELY BE, UM, MUCH MORE HIGHLY UTILIZED THAN IT IS RIGHT NOW.

SO WE CAN SHOW THE ITEM HEARD AND TO RETURN WITH AN ADDITIONAL UPDATE AT THE APPROPRIATE TIME.

WHILE WE HAVE COMMISSIONER BHATT ON THE LINE, UH, COMMISSIONER BHATT, YOU BROUGHT UP THE, THE ISSUE OF WHEN THE 72ND STREET, UM, COMMUNITY CENTER GOES UNDER CONSTRUCTION, THE LOSS OF THE PARKING. UM, COMMISSIONER BHATT, I JUST WANT TO PUT OUT FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION, I KNOW WE HAVE 2 ITEMS PENDING AT NEIGHBORHOODS ABOUT A UNIFIED VALET SYSTEM, ONE FOR 41ST STREET, ANOTHER ONE, UH, FOR, FOR SOUTH BEACH, BUT PERHAPS IT MIGHT BE BENEFICIAL, UM, JUST THROWING OUT THERE THE IDEA TO YOU, COMMISSIONER, UM, TO EXPLORE FOR THAT AREA, PERHAPS A UNIFIED VALET SYSTEM TO, TO, TO HELP FACILITATE PARKING IN, IN THAT AREA. JUST WANTED TO USE THE OPPORTUNITY TO, SINCE WE'RE IN THE SUNSHINE.

UH, TO PLANT THAT SEED IN YOUR HEAD, COMMISSIONER.

YEAH, THANK YOU. I, I DEFINITELY, UM, UH, REVIEW THAT WITH INTEREST AND LISTEN TO THE DISCUSSIONS AT NEIGHBORHOODS. UM, YOU KNOW, I'M, I'M MINDFUL OF NOT ADDING COST TO ANYBODY'S PARKING ER EXPERIENCE, ESPECIALLY IN THAT NEIGHBORHOOD. AND SO THERE HAVE BEEN LOTS OF CONVERSATIONS WITH WILL AND WITH JOSE IN TRANSPORTATION ABOUT HAVING PARKING TROLLEY CIRCUITS SO THAT, UM, YOU CAN HOP ON, HOP OFF A TROLLEY, GET FROM YOUR PARKING SPOT TO YOUR DESTINATION, WHETHER IT'S THE BANDSHELL OR, UM, YOU KNOW, A RESTAURANT SOMEWHERE ALONG THE, THE, THE PATH. AND SO, UM, I THINK THERE ARE TWO VERY VIABLE, UM, WAYS TO MOVE FORWARD AND TO MAKE THIS AS EASY AS POSSIBLE FOR EVERYBODY.

THAT'S IT.

YEP, WE'RE GOOD. THANK YOU.

COMMISSIONER FERNANDEZ, UH, WHY DON'T WE HEAR, UH, NB11? OKAY.

[NB 11. REFERRAL TO DISCUSS ELIMINATING THE CURRENT 30-DAY WAITING PERIOD FOR NEW CITY EMPLOYEES TO RECEIVE BENEFITS, INCLUDING HEALTH INSURANCE FOR PLAN PARTICIPANTS INSURED UNDER THE CITY'S SELF-FUNDED HEALTH PLAN, AND TO REVIEW THE FINANCIAL AND OPERATIONAL IMPACT OF IMPLEMENTING COVERAGE EFFECTIVE UPON HIRE.]

YOU READ IT IN? NB11. REFERRAL TO DISCUSS ELIMINATING THE CURRENT 30-DAY WAITING PERIOD FOR NEW CITY EMPLOYEES TO RECEIVE BENEFITS, INCLUDING HEALTH INSURANCE FOR PLAN PARTICIPANTS INSURED UNDER THE CITY'S SELF-FUNDED HEALTH PLAN, AND TO REVIEW THE FINANCIAL AND OPERATIONAL IMPACT OF IMPLEMENTING COVERAGE EFFECTIVE UPON HIRE, MB 11.

THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR. AND THIS ITEM IS PRETTY STRAIGHTFORWARD.

UM, I'VE ALWAYS HAD CONCERNS ABOUT THE, ABOUT THE 30-DAY, UH, WAIT PERIOD, UM, ESPECIALLY WHEN YOU MIGHT HAVE INDIVIDUALS WITH PRE-EXISTING CONDITIONS, UH, THAT MIGHT BE LEAVING ONE JOB, COMING TO ANOTHER JOB, OR PERHAPS PEOPLE THAT MIGHT NOT EVEN BE EMPLOYED AT, AT THE MOMENT THAT HAVE NO ACCESS TO HEALTHCARE AND THEN S- UH, START, UH, AND BE FACING THIS, UH, 30-DAY WAIT PERIOD. I KNOW NOTHING IS AS SIMPLE AS IT APPEARS, UM, BUT IF YOU ALLOW ME, MR. CHAIR, I'D LIKE TO RECOGNIZE OUR, OUR DIRECTOR OF HUMAN RESOURCES TO WALK US THROUGH THIS ITEM.

GOOD MORNING, MARLA ALPIZAR, DIRECTOR OF HUMAN RESOURCES.

THANK YOU, COMMISSIONER. THANK YOU, CHAIR. UM, THIS IS AN ITEM. THIS WOULD BE THE WILL OF THE COMMISSION AS FAR AS, UM, THE ELIMINATION OF THE WAITING PERIOD. IT WOULD COME WITH A COST, AN ADMINISTRATIVE COST, AND I DO WANT TO, UH, MENTION TO THE COMMISSION THAT ADMINISTRATIVE COST WOULD INCLUDE A, A, AN ADDITIONAL HEADCOUNT IN ORDER TO, UM, DO THE WORK OF MAINTAINING THAT EARLIER ENROLLMENT PERIOD, UH, SORRY, WAITING PERIOD, UH, ELIMINATION OF THE WAITING PERIOD. THE ENROLLMENT PERIOD, WHICH WOULD BE 30 DAYS,

[01:15:02]

EVEN IF YOUR COVERAGE BECAME EFFECTIVE, FOR EXAMPLE, ON DAY ONE, WE WOULD STILL BE REQUIRED TO MAINTAIN AN ENROLLMENT PERIOD OF 30 DAYS, UH, TO ALLOW THE EMPLOYEE TIME TO MAKE A DECISION.

WALK ME THROUGH WHY WE WOULD, UH, REQUIRE AN EXTRA HEADCOUNT.

SO SOME OF THE DETAILS, UM, ARE IN THE MEMO TO SUMMARIZE, UM, LET'S SAY I, I START AND I HAVE THIS 30-DAY TIME TO MAKE A DECISION.

IN THAT 30-DAY TIME TO MAKE A DECISION, RIGHT NOW, UM, THE DEDUCTIONS WOULD NOT BE SET UP. SO AFTER THE EMPLOYEE, UH, WOULD MAKE A DECISION, YOU HAVE TO GO BACK AND PUT IN THE DEDUCTIONS BACK TO DAY ONE, DEPENDING ON THE PLAN THAT THEY CHOOSE, AND PRORATE THAT BASED ON THEIR DATE OF HIRE. RIGHT NOW, OUR DEDUCTIONS ARE, ARE BASICALLY THE FIRST OF THE MONTH, AND SO THEY SORT OF ALIGN WITH, UM, A REGULAR PATTERN, AND THERE'S NOT ANY PRORATING GOING ON. SO THIS WOULD PRORATE EACH INDIVIDUAL PERSON'S, UM, PERIOD BACK TO THEIR DATE OF HIRE. THAT WOULD BE ONE ADMINISTRATIVE BURDEN. THEN YOU HAVE TO RECONCILE THE BILLS WITH THE CARRIERS TO MATCH THAT, UH, DATE AFTER THEY'RE ENROLLED AND YOU SUBMIT THAT, UH, EMPLOYEE INFORMATION TO THE CARRIERS. UM, THEY'VE ALREADY BILLED YOU, AND NOW THEY HAVE TO GO BACK EVERY MONTH AND ADJUST THE BILL FOR THE INDIVIDUALIZED ENROLLMENT PERIODS FROM THE PRIOR MONTH. IT'S ALL DOABLE, IT'S JUST GOING TO COME WITH A, A H- HIGHER ADMINISTRATIVE BURDEN.

A- AND GENERAL BALLPARK, HOW MANY HEALTHCARE-ELIGIBLE EMPLOYEES DO WE HAVE THAT START NEW, UH, WITHIN MIAMI BEACH, LET'S CALL IT EACH MONTH? I, I GUESS I. SO OUR PART-TIMERS DON'T HAVE HEALTHCARE, BUT WE, OUR PART-TIMERS ARE A SMALL PERCENTAGE OF OUR EM- UM, EMPLOYEE BASE.

OUR FULL-TIME EMPLOYEES, I WOULD, I'M GONNA JUST GUESS, I, UH, I DON'T HAVE THIS NUMBER IN FRONT OF ME. APPROXIMATELY TWO-THIRDS OF OUR FULL-TIME EMPLOYEES ELECT THE HEALTH COVERAGE. UM, I DO WANT TO MENTION THAT- RIGHT, BUT WE'RE JUST TALKING ABOUT NEW EMPLOYEES. DO WE HAVE, I WOULD ASSUME, LESS THAN 10 NEW EMPLOYEES PER MONTH, RIGHT? THAT ARE FULL-TIME? THAT'S A GREAT QUESTION.

UM... SO I'M TRYING TO DO MATH IN MY HEAD. WE D- WE HIRE ABOUT 200 EMPLOYEES A YEAR.

YEP.

SO THEN DIVIDING THAT BY SO ABOUT 10 TO 12, ABOUT 10 TO 15.

RIGHT, THEY'RE KIND OF, THEY KIND OF CLUSTER DEPEND- OF COURSE.

POLICE AND FIRE PARTICULARLY CLUSTER EMPLOYEES. I DO WANT TO MENTION THAT THIS, THIS, THIS ITEM IS WRITTEN TO JUST APPLY TO THE, THE CITY OFFERED BENEFITS.

POLICE AND FIRE HAVE THEIR OWN HEALTH TRUSTS, AND RIGHT NOW THEIR HEALTH TRUSTS ALIGN WITH THE, UM, THE 30-DAY, UH, WAIT PERIOD THAT THE CITY CURRENTLY DOES WITH OUR HEALTH INSURANCE, AND WE WOULD NEED TO BARGAIN ANY CHANGE TO THEIR ENROLLMENT, UH, EXCUSE ME, ANY CHANGE TO THEIR WAITING PERIOD, AND IT W- THE COSTS THAT YOU SEE IN THIS MEMO ARE JUST FOR THE CITY PLANS, NOT FOR THE. SO I GUESS WHERE I'M GOING WITH THAT THEN, MARLA, IF THAT 10 TO 15 NEW EMPLOYEES PER MONTH INCLUDES POLICE AND FIRE, AND THEY'RE NOT GOING TO BE PART OF THIS PROGRAM, SO I, I KNOW JUST USING ABSOLUTE ESTIMATES, PUTTING MY, YOU KNOW, HAND IN THE, FINGER IN THE AIR HERE, BUT WE'RE TALKING 3 TO 5 MAYBE NEW EMPLOYEES PER MONTH. I'M JUST SURPRISED THAT THAT WOULD TAKE A FULL DEDICATED NEW HEADCOUNT TO HELP BRING THAT ON.

THE, BECAUSE WE'RE SELF-INSURED, OUR, ALL OF OUR CLAIMS ARE PAID, ALL OF OUR BILLING IS DONE, UM, WITH EACH CARRIER.

YEAH.

UM, IT IS RIGHT NOW WE HAVE, UM, ONE FULL-TIME PERSON DEDICATED JUST TO BILLING AND TO ADJUST EVERY SINGLE PERSON'S INDIVIDUALIZED BILLS AND, AND, UM, DEDUCTIONS, NOT JUST TO START THEM, BUT TO GO BACK IN TIME AND READJUST THEM.

IT, IT WILL BE AN ADMINISTRATIVE.

AND, AND I APOLOGIZE IF IT'S IN THE MEMO, BUT THAT ADMINISTRATIVE CHARGE, WOULD THAT BE A ONE-TIME THING TO IMPLEMENT THIS PROGRAM, OR IS THAT AN ANNUAL RECURRING COST? SO THE ANNUAL RECURRING COST IS THE ESTIMATE OF CLAIMS, YEP.

WHICH IS 325,000 DOLLARS FOR THE EXTRA DAYS OF CLAIMS WE WOULD BE PAYING, AND THEN THE, UM, THE, THE REST OF THE ESTIMATE IS THE ADMINISTRATIVE PERSON.

TURN IT OVER TO COMMISSIONER FERNANDEZ, JUST, AND COMMISSIONER DOMINGUEZ.

AND, AND MR. CHAIR, I'M HAPPY TO CONTINUE THIS ITEM SO THAT I CAN GET SOME ADDITIONAL FEEDBACK FROM, UH, FROM MARLA AND THE HR DEPARTMENT. IF I COULD JUST GET A CLARITY, POLICE AND FIRE, THEY DON'T GET, UH, HEALTH BENEFITS ON DAY ONE? THEY'RE, UM, THE SAME AS THE CITY EMPLOYEES RIGHT NOW, UH, WITH THE CITY PLANS, WHICH IS,

[01:20:03]

UM, 30 DAYS AFTER THE FIRST OF THE MONTH FROM THEIR DATE OF HIRE.

AND THAT'S A CONCERN T- SORRY? BUT THAT, FOR ME, THAT'S A CONCERN, BECAUSE I DO BELIEVE, YOU KNOW, THE VERY MINIMUM POLICE AND FIRE POSITIONS, E- OCEAN RESCUE POSITIONS, ANY FULL-TIME POSITION WHERE INDIVIDUALS ARE DOING SOMETHING WHERE THEY'RE PUTTING THEMSELVES AT RISK ON BEHALF OF THE CITY, FROM MY PERSPECTIVE, YOU KNOW, IT'S SOMETHING THAT SHOULD BE ON DAY ONE. UM, OBVIOUSLY, AGAIN, AS YOU MENTIONED, THAT'S SUBJECT TO COLLECTIVE BARGAINING PROVISIONS. UM, SO I'M HAPPY TO CONTINUE THIS ITEM SO THAT I CAN GET MORE, UH, MORE INFORMATION FROM STAFF, BUT I'D BENEFIT FROM ANY OTHER FEEDBACK FROM THE DAIS, UH, THAT I CAN TAKE BACK WITH ME AS WE WORK ON THIS ITEM.

COMMISSIONER DOMINGUEZ.

THANK YOU. UM, I KNOW I'VE WORKED IN THE PRIVATE SECTOR.

I'VE NEVER SEEN ANYTHING LIKE THIS. UH, IT SOUNDS LIKE A GOOD OPPORTUNITY FOR MIAMI BEACH TO ENTICE WORKERS. DO OTHER MUNICIPALITIES OFFER THIS ON DAY ONE? THANK YOU, COMMISSIONER. UM, THE COUNTY DOES, AND MOST MUNICIPALITIES DO HAVE A WAITING PERIOD OF 30 DAYS, 60 DAYS, BUT THE COUNTY DOES OFFER DAY ONE.

SO WE'LL CONTINUE THIS.

YEAH, IF ONE CLARIFICATION, UH, UM, MARLA, THE, UH, FOR DURING THAT PERIOD, THEY DO HAVE ACCESS TO, UH, WORKERS' COMP INSURANCE, RIGHT? SO IF THEY WERE INJURED IN THAT 30-DAY PERIOD, WORKERS' COMP WOULD STILL...

YES, THROUGH THE CHAIR, YES.

SO JUST, JUST TO, TO CLARIFY THAT. OKAY.

AND, AND JUST ONE LAST MOMENT, UM, I CAN ALSO APPROACH THE HEALTH, IF YOU WERE INTERESTED IN, COMMISSIONER, THE, UM, CONVERSATION BEING BROADER THAN JUST CITY HEALTH PLAN, AND ALSO, UH, UNDERSTANDING WHAT THAT COST WOULD BE FOR THE POLICE AND FIRE HEALTH TRUST, I CAN WORK ON THOSE NUMBERS.

SO WE CAN SHOW THE ITEM, UH, ITEM WAS HEARD AND TO RETURN WITH AN UPDATE WHEN APPROPRIATE.

THANK YOU.

THANK YOU, COMMISSIONER. THANK YOU, MARLA. UH, LET'S HEAR NB12, AND UH, IF THERE'S ANY OTHER IMPORTANT ITEMS MY COLLEAGUES WANT TO HEAR, LET ME KNOW, BUT ABSENT THAT, I THINK WE'LL WRAP UP AFTER NB12, UH, GIVEN WE HAVE A

[NB 12. DISCUSS A POTENTIAL INCENTIVE PROGRAM FOR HOTEL AND HOSPITALITY EMPLOYEES REPORTING HUMAN OR SEX TRAFFICKING.]

LONG NIGHT AHEAD.

OKAY. UH, NB12 DISCUSSED THE POTENTIAL INCENTIVE PROGRAM FOR HOTEL AND HOSPITALITY EMPLOYEES, UH, REPORTING HUMAN OR SEX TRAFFICKING, NB12.

THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR AND MR. GREEN. UM, SO THIS IS MY ITEM, AND, YOU KNOW, I'D, I'D LIKE TO DISCUSS A INCENTIVE PROGRAM FOR HOTEL AND HOSPITALITY EMPLOYEES TO REPORT HUMAN, SUSPECTED HUMAN OR SEX TRAFFICKING. THIS WOULD ONLY BE PAID OUT IF IT LEADS TO A CONVICTION. SO, YOU KNOW, IF SOMEONE CALLS AND THEY SUSPECT SOMETHING, IT'S LIKE A CRIME, UH, CRIME STOPPERS. IF THEY CALL AND SUSPECT SOMETHING AND IT TURNS OUT TO BE, UM, NOT A, UH, A REAL SITUATION, UM, IT'S GREAT THAT WE HAVE PEOPLE, YOU KNOW, RINGING THE ALARM BELL ON SUSPICIONS, BUT THIS WOULD ONLY BE PAID OUT IF IT LED TO A ARREST AND CONVICTION.

UM, AND I THINK THAT THIS COULD BE A GREAT PROGRAM SINCE WE HAVE SUCH A, UM, A, A, A LARGE, YOU KNOW, POPULATION THAT, YOU KNOW, WE'RE, WE'RE DOING A GREAT JOB ON HUMAN AND SEX TRAFFICKING AND COMBATING THAT, BUT IT, IT HELPS TO HAVE PEOPLE, FRONTLINE WORKERS THAT ARE IN OUR HOTEL AND HOSPITALITY INDUSTRY. SO I THINK THIS WOULD BE A VERY WORTHWHILE PROGRAM.

AND HELLO, UH, OFFICER ROBINSON, CHIEF MAJOR. I DON'T KNOW WHAT RANK YOU ARE AT THIS POINT.

UH, GOOD MORNING, MA'AM. IAN ROBINSON. I CURRENTLY OVERSEE, UH, CRIMINAL INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION, OBVIOUSLY OUR, UH, POLICE DEPARTMENT. UM, SO ONCE FUNDING IS IDENTIFIED FOR THIS, I'VE ALREADY REACHED OUT TO CRIME STOPPERS TO SEE IF THERE'S A PROGRAM WE CAN PUT IN PLACE FOR, UH, FOLKS CALLING IN, UM, INFORMATION ABOUT HUMAN TRAFFICKING, AND THAT LEADS TO A SUCCESSFUL ARREST. UM, SPOKEN TO STAFF, OUR HUMAN TRAFFICKING SQUAD AND LEADERSHIP ABOUT THIS. UM, IF POSSIBLE, WE DON'T WANT IT SPECIFICALLY IDENTIFIED WHERE IT'S JUST HOSPITALITY EMPLOYEES, BUT MORE SO EVERYBODY OR ANYBODY THAT CALLS IN A COMPLAINT OR INFORMATION, A TIP ON HUMAN TRAFFICKING. SO IT WOULD GO THAT SOMEBODY CALLS IT IN, AND I BELIEVE THERE'S HUMAN TRAFFICKING OCCURRING HERE. UM, OUR DETECTIVES WOULD INVESTIGATE THAT, UH, VET IT TO SEE IF IT'S ACCURATE. IF IT IS ACCURATE AND THERE IS AN ARREST MADE AS A RESULT, WE WOULD THEN CONTACT OUR FRIENDS OVER AT CRIME STOPPERS.

THERE'S A CERTAIN, UM, POT OF MONEY SET ASIDE JUST FOR THAT, AND WE PUT THE TWO OF THEM IN CONNECTION, AND THEREBY, HOPEFULLY, UM, THEY WOULD GET A REWARD FOR CALLING IN THAT TIP.

AND, AND CRIME STOPPERS, I'VE HAD CONVERSATIONS WITH THEM AS WELL. THEY'RE A WONDERFUL ORGANIZATION. UM, AND, AND I KNOW THAT THEY, AND I WANT TO JUST CONFIRM WITH YOUR CONVERSATIONS THAT YOU'VE HAD WITH THEM, THEY WOULD EARMARK ANY TYPE OF DOLLARS FOR CASES THAT EITHER ORIGINATED IN MIAMI BEACH OR MAYBE THE PERPETRATOR WAS CAUGHT IN MIAMI BEACH, BUT THERE WAS A MIAMI BEACH CONNECTION WHERE THEY WOULD HAVE THAT THOSE FUNDS EARMARKED FOR FOLKS THAT WHERE. YES,

[01:25:01]

MA'AM.

YES, MA'AM.

OCCURRED IN MIAMI BEACH.

SO IT WOULD BE MIAMI BEACH CENTRIC. SO ANYBODY THAT CALLED IN A TIP ON MIAMI BEACH, AND IF THERE WAS AN ARREST MADE ON MIAMI BEACH, THAT POT OF MONEY SET ASIDE WOULD JUST BE FOR THAT, UH, THAT PURPOSE.

THANK YOU.

MR. CFO, UM... DO WE HAVE TO HAVE A POT THERE, OR IS IT, UH, WE CAN ADVERTISE THIS PROGRAM, AND TO THE EXTENT THAT, UH, IT'S UTILIZED, THEN WE COULD DO, UH, KIND OF A INTER-YEAR BUDGET AMENDMENT? I- I WOULD- I WOULD RECOMMEND THAT IT WOULD BE HANDLED THROUGH, UH, AN ALLOCATION.

UM, OBVIOUSLY THE BUDGET'S GOING TO BE FINALIZED TONIGHT, UM, SO THERE'S A COUPLE WAYS THE COMMITTEE CAN- CAN GO FORWARD WITH THIS, IS, YOU KNOW, TO DIRECT THE ADMINISTRATION TO IMPLEMENT THIS PROGRAM, UM, WITH THE FUNDING BE MULTIPLE WAYS. IT CAN BE EITHER TO BE CREATED AS A A BUDGET ENHANCEMENT TO BE CONSIDERED DURING THE 2028 BUDGET PROCESS.

UH, IT COULD BE HANDLED TONIGHT WITH ONE-TIME MONEY, PERHAPS AN ALLOCATION OF 75,000 DOLLARS, 50,000 DOLLARS, SOME DOLLAR VALUE. UH, SO THERE'S A POT OF MONEY ON A ONE-TIME BASIS, UM, THAT COULD BE GIVEN TOWARDS THIS PROGRAM, AND THEN, YOU KNOW, I- IF, IF AND WHEN THAT POT IS, IS, IT COULD BE ROLLED OVER FROM YEAR TO YEAR AS IF IT ISN'T UTILIZED, AND IF IT NEEDS TO BE REPLENISHED, THE, THE POLICE COULD BRING BACK A ONE-TIME BUDGET ENHANCEMENT IN A YEAR, 2 OR 3, OR WHENEVER THE BU- BU- BUCKET IS, UH, REPLE- NEEDS TO BE REPLENISHED. UH, BUT SO IT GO BACK TO COMMISSION DIRECT TO IMPLEMENT THE PROGRAM, THE, THE, BUT YOU DO NEED TO HAVE DOLLARS TO IDENTIFY TO DO THAT. SO I CAN AGAIN EITHER BE HANDLED THROUGH, WE'RE GETTING TO THE POINT WHERE THINGS ARE GOING TO START CONVERTING PROBABLY IN OCTOBER TO RECOMMEND TO BE A BUDGET ENHANCER 28, BUT THERE IS AN OPPORTUNITY TONIGHT, SO I MEAN THE SPONSOR IS HERE, UM, SO THERE COULD BE AN OPPORTUNITY TO REQUEST AN ALLOCATION OF ONE-TIME MONEY.

SO AS PART OF THE PUBLIC BENEFITS FOR UM, A A PARTICULAR PROJECT THAT'S COMING UP, THE PART OF THAT PUBLIC BENEFIT WAS A HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS TO GO SPECIFICALLY TOWARDS THIS.

SO...

SO MAYBE PERHAPS IT COULD JUST BE TO IMPLEMENT TO, LET ME SEE, RETURN TO COMMISSION WITH A FAVORABLE RECOMMENDATION TO DIRECT ADMINISTRATION TO IMPLEMENT, UH, THE HUMAN OR SEX TRAFFICKING REPORTING INCENTIVE PROGRAM AS PRESENTED, UH, WITH FUNDING, UM, WITH S- WITH FUNDING AS AS IDENTIFIED IN A, WAS IT DEVELOPMENT ORDER? I I DON'T KNOW. I DON'T REMEMBER.

IT'LL BE CONTINGENT ON THE REFERENDUM.

OH, OKAY.

BUT PERHAPS YEAH.

IF THAT DOESN'T PASS, THEN WE COULD COME BACK TO THE DRAWING BOARD YEAH.

UH, MID-YEAR.

OKAY, SO, SO IF I MAY, SO AGAIN, RETURN TO COMMISSION WITH A FAVORABLE RECOMMENDATION, DIRECT ADMINISTRATION IMPLEMENT, UH, HUMAN OR SEX TRAFFICKING REPORTING INCENTIVE PROGRAM, UH, AS PRESENTED AND, UH, TO BE, UH, AS PRESENTED, AND THAT WOULD INCLUDE THE, THE FUNDING ALLOCATION. SO, UH, IF IT ISN'T, THEN, YOU KNOW, OBVIOUSLY PROBABLY ANOTHER REFERRAL TO DISCUSS BUDGET ENHANCER 28, BUT IT SEEMS TO BE RESOLVED. SO I THINK THAT THAT WOULD BE THE MOTION. UM, ASSUMING THE REFERENDUM GOES IN, THEN THE POLICE WOULD HAVE THEIR, THEIR ALLOCATION WHEN THOSE FUNDS ARE RECEIVED, AND THE PROGRAM COULD BE ROLLED OUT. SO I THINK THAT'S THE MOTION. IF I, WHO'S MAKING THAT MOTION? I CAN MAKE THAT MOTION.

OKAY.

AND I'LL SECOND.

OKAY. ALL IN FAVOR? AYE.

HEARING THE ITEM PASSES 3 NOTHING.

UNLESS YOU'RE SORRY FOR, UH, THE EXTENSION, UH, BUT I GOT A MESSAGE, UH, NB4.

LET'S, UH, HEAR THAT, AND THEN

[NB 4. DISCUSS THE ESTIMATED COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH PROVIDING WATER TAXI AND CONNECTOR SHUTTLE SERVICES FOR FOUR (4) DAYS OF THE BOAT/YACHT SHOW, INCLUDING WATER TAXI VESSELS, CONNECTOR SHUTTLES, AND ASSOCIATED TRANSPORTATION SERVICES.]

WE CAN CLOSE THINGS OUT.

OKAY, LET ME GET TO... NB4, DISCUSS THE ESTIMATED COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH PROVIDING WATER TAXI AND CONNECTOR SHUTTLE SERVICES FOR 4 DAYS OF BOAT YACHT SHOW, INCLUDING WATER TAXI VESSELS, CONNECTOR SHUTTLES, AND ASSOCIATED TRANSPORTATION SERVICES.

WHO'S THAT? NB4.

WELCOME.

THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR. GOOD MORNING, COMMITTEE MEMBERS.

JOSE GONZALEZ, TRANSPORTATION DIRECTOR. SO EVERY, EVERY YEAR WE WORK WITH INFORMA AND WITH THE BOAT SHOW TO DEVELOP THE TRANSPORTATION PLAN FOR THAT, THAT YEAR OF BOAT SHOW. HISTORICALLY, BOAT SHOW, UH, PROVIDES ITS OWN TRANSPORTATION SERVICES, MEANING AT NO COST TO THE CITY, AND THEY PROVIDE A VERY COMPREHENSIVE, ROBUST NETWORK OF SERVICE. UM, AND SO, QUITE HONESTLY, WE'VE ALWAYS USED THEM AS A GREAT EXAMPLE OF A PARTNER WHO COMES TO OUR CITY, AND THEY KNOW THAT THEIR EVENT IS GOING TO, UH, CREATE SOME TRAFFIC IMPACTS, BUT THEY, ALONG WITH THEIR EVENT, THEY ALSO BRING SOME SOLUTIONS.

HOWEVER, THIS YEAR, ACTUALLY JUST VERY RECENTLY, ON SEPTEMBER 3RD, INFORMA, UH, COMMUNICATED WITH THE CITY, AND THEY THEY SENT A LETTER, WHICH IS ATTACHED TO THIS ITEM. IT'S IT'S ATTACHMENT B, AND IN THAT LETTER, UH, INFORMA IS REQUESTING THE OPERATION OF 8 WATER TAXI VESSELS AS PART OF THEIR UPCOMING 2027, UH, BOAT SHOW. UM, AND SO WHAT, YOU KNOW, IN THE SPIRIT OF PARTNERSHIP, WHAT WE'VE DONE IS WE'VE WE'VE AT LEAST LOOKED AT WHAT THEIR, YOU KNOW, THEIR REQUEST AND WHAT IT WOULD COST.

WHAT THEY'RE. AND JOSE,

[01:30:01]

TO CLARIFY, THEY WERE ASKING US TO BEAR THE COST OF THAT, OR THEY WERE SAYING- YES, THEY'RE ASKING THE CITY TO BEAR THE COST OF THIS ENHANCED WATER TAXI SERVICE FOR, UH, BOAT SHOW 2027. AND I CALL IT ENHANCED BECAUSE THEY WOULD BE COMPLEMENTING OUR CURRENT WATER TAXI SERVICE, SUCH THAT OUR CURRENT WATER TAXI SERVICE WOULD CONTINUE TO OPERATE, BUT THE SERVICE WOULD BE AUGMENTED, AND THAT'S WHERE THE 8, YOU KNOW, 8 VESSELS COME IN. AS AS YOU ALL ARE AWARE, WE ONLY OPERATE 2 VESSELS MONDAY THROUGH FRIDAY, AND THAT'S AT MOST. UM, DURING THE AFTERNOON PERIOD, IT'S 2 VESSELS. ALL OTHER TIMES, IT'S ONLY 1 VESSEL. SO WE'VE TAKEN A LOOK AT THEIR REQUEST, AND WHAT WE'VE DONE IS WE, YOU KNOW, USING OUR, THE COST FOR WATER TAXI SERVICE, AS WELL AS, UM, THE, THE COST FOR ART WEEK, WE USED THAT AS A BASIS, AND WE TOOK THOSE ESTIMATES, PRORATED THEM, AND FOR 5 DAYS OF BOAT SHOW TO PROVIDE THE LEVEL OF SERVICE THAT INFORMA IS REQUESTING, UH, OF THE CITY, IT WOULD BE APPROXIMATELY 135,000 DOLLARS FOR THE 5 DAYS.

THERE'S A CERTAIN LEVEL OF IRONY THAT THE BOAT SHOW, UH, HAS PULLED BACK THEIR BOAT SERVICE AND ASKING THE C- CITY TO DO SO. UM, I DON'T KNOW IF, UH, WE HAVE STAFF HERE THAT WAS, UH, TASKED WITH NEGOTIATING, BUT WAS THE MOVE BACK TO ALONG INDIAN CREEK, ONE OF THE WAYS WE GOT COMFORTABLE WITH THAT WAS BECAUSE OF SOME OF THE, UM, MITIGATION EFFORTS THAT INFORMA PUT FORWARD THAT WOULD HELP MITIGATE TRAFFIC, RIGHT? OF- OF COURSE, ONE OF THE THINGS WE WERE ALL VERY CONCERNED ABOUT WAS HOW THAT WOULD IMPACT TRAFFIC ALONG INDIAN CREEK, AND I CAN REMEMBER HAVING MEETINGS WITH, UH, REPRESENTATIVES THERE, AND THEY LAID OUT A PLAN AND SAID, WELL, THIS IS WHAT WE'RE GOING TO DO TO MITIGATE TRAFFIC. I DON'T KNOW IF THAT WAS CONTINGENT ON THE TRA- UH, CONTRACT BEING EXECUTED OR THINGS LIKE THAT, BUT IT WAS CERTAINLY A SELLING POINT, IF YOU WILL. FRANCIS, MAYBE YOU WANT TO COME UP AND TALK TO THAT.

UM, THAT HAPPENED IN YEAR ONE. I DON'T KNOW, I DON'T WANT TO SAY I'M CONCERNED, BUT I'M POINTING OUT THAT NOW IN YEAR TWO, WHAT WAS USED AS KIND OF A CARROT FOR HOW WE COULD GET THE NEIGHBORHOOD COMFORTABLE MOVING IT BACK TO INDIAN CREEK, THAT THAT'S SORT OF BEEN TAKEN AWAY. ANY RHYME OR REASON FOR WHY THAT HAPPENED AND THANK YOU, MR. CHAIR.

WHY I SHOULD LOOK AT IT AS LIKE A BAIT AND SWITCH? THANK YOU. FRANCIS VIASIO, INTERIM DIRECTOR OF TOURISM AND CULTURE. YOU ARE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT. IT WAS ONE OF THE KEY POINTS OF PART OF THE NEGOTIATION FOR THE AGREEMENT THAT THEY MADE SURE THAT THEY WERE GOING TO MITIGATE TRAFFIC AND CLOSURES.

NO CLOSURES WERE EVEN ALLOWED ON COLLINS, AND THEIR LOAD IN AND LOAD OUTS ARE LIMITED TO TIMES THAT ARE NOT DURING RUSH HOUR.

IN THE AGREEMENT, IT DOES STATE THAT PART OF THE APPLICATION PROCESS EVERY YEAR, THEY HAVE TO SUBMIT A TRANSPORTATION PLAN, WHICH INCLUDES, WHICH MAY INCLUDE, UH, WATER TAXIS, WHICH IS SOMETHING, AS JOSE ALLUDED TO, IS SOMETHING THAT THEY'VE ALWAYS DONE, THEY'VE ALWAYS INCLUDED. I THINK THE CONVERSATION MAY HAVE COME ABOUT BECAUSE OF THE INITIATIVES THAT THE CITY HAS DONE DURING ART WEEK, AND MAYBE THEY'RE LEANING ON THAT AND AND NOTICING, UH, THAT THERE MAY BE AN OPPORTUNITY. I'VE PARTICIPATED WITH JOSE ON THESE MEETINGS, UM, WE'VE SHARED THAT DURING ART WEEK THERE'S CLOSE TO 30 EVENTS. UH, WE'VE HAD CONVERSATIONS WITH DIFFERENT FAIRS WHERE- VERSUS DURING THIS TIME PERIOD, IT'S JUST ONE, WHICH IS A MAJOR EVENT. IT'S A- AN ECONOMIC DRIVER FOR THE CITY. CAN'T TAKE THAT AWAY, BUT- AND WHAT IS ALSO UNIQUE ABOUT THIS IS THE OFFICIAL ART BASEL THAT WE HOST, THEY'RE NOT HAVING ONE OF THEIR OFFICIAL EVENTS ON INDIAN CREEK. SO THIS IS VERY DIFFERENT WHERE INFORMA CAME TO US AND SAID, HERE'S THIS IDEA, WE'D LIKE TO BRING IT BACK TO INDIAN CREEK TO GET COMFORTABLE WITH THAT. HERE'S OUR MITIGATION PLANS, AND NOW THAT'S KIND OF, THE RUG'S KIND OF BEING PULLED OUT FROM UNDER US. UM, TELL ME, DO WE HAVE A MULTI-YEAR CONTRACT IN PLACE, UH, WITH THE BOAT SHOW HAVING IT THERE? WE DO. I BELIEVE IT'S UNTIL 2030, I CAN CONFIRM, BUT IT'S A MULTI-YEAR.

SO IS THAT PART OF THE CONTRACT ABOUT. AND IT'S NOT A SPONSORSHIP, IT'S JUST YEAH, ABOUT THEM PROVIDING FURRY SERVICE? I'M SORRY? IS THAT PART OF THE CONTRACT, UH, NO, IT DOES NOT REQUIRE IT.

IT JUST SAYS THAT AS YOUR MOBILITY TRANSPORTATION PLAN, THAT THAT COULD BE ONE OF THE COMPONENTS, BUT IT DOES NOT REQUIRE IT.

THROUGH THE CHAIR, AS I PULLED UP THE CONTRACT, UM, AND I THINK FRANCIS IS IS CORRECT, BUT THEY MUST PROVIDE TRANSPORTATION FOR THEIR ATTENDEES TO LIMIT THE USE OF PRIVATE VEHICLES

[01:35:01]

IN CONNECTION WITH THE ANNUAL SHOW. SO WE DON'T SPECIFY WHETHER IT'S WATER TAXIS OR SHUTTLES. WE HAVE IN, IN PARENTHESES EXAMPLE, WATER TAXIS AND SHUTTLES, BUT THEY CAN CHOOSE TO USE SHUTTLES OR, OR WATER TAXIS, BUT IT IS, IT IS REQUIRED.

UH, ANY OF MY COLLEAGUES HAVE ANYTHING TO SAY? I DON'T SEE THE INCENTIVE FOR US TO SAY, OH, WE'RE GOING TO SUBSIDIZE THIS TO THE TUNE OF 130,000 DOLLARS FOR IN THE SECOND YEAR OF A CONTRACT OF, WHAT, 5 YEARS? UH, THAT'S BEEN IN PLACE WHERE THE ENTIRETY OF WHY WE GOT COMFORTABLE MOVING IT INTO A HIGH TRAFFIC AREAS BE- IN LARGE PART BECAUSE OF THE TRAFFIC MITIGATION PLANS THAT WERE PITCHED BY THE, UH, SPONSOR OR EXHIBITOR. UM.

IS THERE ANY, AND SORRY IF IT'S BEEN SAID ALREADY, BUT IS THERE ANY FUNDING THAT THE COUNTY CAN HELP US WITH ON THIS ASPECT? UM, THEY'RE DOING IT HERE, BUT IT'S FOR THE ENTIRE COUNTY. CAN THEY HELP? SO, UM, WE HAVEN'T BROACHED THE COUNTY WITH THIS, YOU KNOW, PARTICULAR SITUATION, BUT WE HAVE EVERY YEAR FOR ART WEEK, AND EVERY YEAR THE COUNTY ESSENTIALLY SAYS NO, THAT THEY DON'T HAVE FUNDING TO PARTICIPATE. UH, FOR ART WEEK, YOU KNOW, THAT'S A MUCH MORE REGIONAL EVENT, AND WE'VE ASKED THE COUNTY TO PROVIDE REGIONAL TRANSIT SERVICES, MORE BUSES, MORE FREQUENT SERVICE ACROSS THE CAUSEWAYS, AND YEAR AFTER YEAR, THE COUNTY HAS, UM, YOU KNOW, DENIED THAT REQUEST IF IT'S EITHER FUNDING RELATED OR THEY DON'T HAVE ENOUGH DRIVERS OR. AND IS THE CONTRACT WITH THE THE BOAT SHOW ALREADY SIGNED AND ALL SET? CAN THEY STEP UP TO THE PLATE AND OFFER MORE SO THAT THEIR SHOW IS EASED.

YOU MEAN IS THE FOR THE YACHT SHOW? FOR THE YACHT SHOW? YES, IT WAS, IT'S A MULTI-YEAR, IT'S A 5-YEAR AGREEMENT, SO LA- THIS WOULD BE THE SECOND, UH, EVENT IN 2027.

AND WITHIN THE AGREEMENT, IS THERE ANY, UM, FINANCIAL, UH, TO THE CITY? ARE THEY GIVING US ANY MONEY? THEY DO. UH, IT'S, I BELIEVE IS IT ALREADY EARMARKED? CAN IT BE- YES.

CAN ANY OF IT BE PUT TOWARDS THIS? I KNOW RICK HAS IT UP, SO HE COULD PROBABLY SAY THE EXACT LANGUAGE, BUT IT'S 250,000, AND IT'S USED FOR THE RESTORATION OF BISCAYNE.

MR. CHAIR.

I'M JUST, I'M GONNA BE VERY SINCERE ABOUT HOW I FEEL ABOUT THIS, UH, BECAUSE THIS IS GONNA TIE PROBABLY TO OTHER CONVERSATIONS ABOUT OTHER AGREEMENTS THAT, THAT OUR BODY IS GOING TO BE DISCUSSING IN, IN THE FUTURE. I DON'T FEEL COMFORTABLE. I, I JUST DON'T FEEL COMFORTABLE.

THESE, THESE ENTITIES MAKE A LOT OF MONEY BY COMING TO MIAMI BEACH, AND UH, AND THIS DAIS HAS HAD SO MANY CONVERSATIONS ABOUT LIMITING THE AMOUNT OF MONEY THAT WE GIVE OUT, SPECIFICALLY ACTUALLY FOR NONPROFIT ENTITIES, AND HERE WE HAVE A FOR-PROFIT VENTURE THAT MAKES A TREMENDOUS AMOUNT OF MONEY FROM BEING HERE IN OUR CITY.

WHY WOULD WE SUBSIDIZE THIS FOR THEM? IT'S IN THEIR AGREEMENT THAT IT'S THEIR RESPONSIBILITY. SO I WANT TO, I WANT TO BE CAREFUL ABOUT THE PRECEDENT THAT WE SET, UH, AND THE MESSAGE THAT WE SEND TO OTHER FOR-PROFIT OPERATORS, UM, THAT, THAT CHOOSE US AS, AS THEIR VENUE. THEY ARE HERE TO CONTRIBUTE TO THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH AND TO PAY TO THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH. THE CITY IS NOT HERE TO SUBSIDIZE THEIR FOR-PROFIT VENTURES. UM, AND THAT, I THINK, APPLIES, IT APPLIES IN THIS CASE, UH, TO, TO THE YACHT SHOW, UM, AND IT'S GONNA APPLY TO OTHER FOR-PROFIT SHOWS THAT ARE NEGOTIATING WITH THE CITY. AND SO I WANT TO JUST SET A VERY, A VERY, YOU KNOW, BROAD MESSAGE OUT THERE AS IT RELATES TO THESE TYPES OF SUBSIDIES.

YEAH, AND I, I AGREE WITH YOU, UM, I DON'T MEAN TO BE DRAMATIC, BUT RUBBED THE WRONG WAY, IF YOU WILL, BY JUST THE TIMING OF THIS, WHERE IT WAS WE HAD THIS BIG DOG AND PONY SHOW ABOUT LET'S MOVE IT HERE, AND HERE'S ALL THE THINGS THAT THIS TREMENDOUS SPONSOR IS GOING TO DO, AND AND, YOU KNOW, BY ALL MEANS, THEY ARE A GREAT PARTNER AND A VALUED PARTNER TO THE CITY, BUT I DON'T LIKE THE YEAR AFTER WE AGREED TO THIS TO ALL OF A SUDDEN COME BACK. IF WE WERE AT THE END OF THE CONTRACT AND WE SAID, OKAY, HERE'S WHAT NEEDS TO BE NEGOTIATED, ALL IS ON THE TABLE, BUT WE SHOWED A TREMENDOUS AMOUNT OF GOOD FAITH, AND WE WERE LEFT, IN A WAY, LOBBYING OUR NEIGHBORS AND OUR RESIDENTS TO SAY, PLEASE TRUST US. WE WANT TO BRING THIS EVENT. IT'S GREAT FOR THE CITY. IT MAY NOT

[01:40:01]

BE GREAT FOR THE NEIGHBORS IN THAT AREA, WHICH IS ALREADY CONGESTED, BUT HERE'S ALL THE MITIGATION EFFORTS THAT WE'VE WORKED WITH TO TRY AND OBTAIN, AND NOW THAT'S JUST BEING PULLED OUT FROM UNDER US. UH, ABSENT HEARING ANYTHING FURTHER, THAT'S HOW I'M FEELING AT THE MOMENT.

I JUST HAVE A QUESTION, FRANCIS. YOU SAID THAT, I'M SORRY, THEY WERE PAYING THE CITY 250,000 TO GO TOWARDS WHAT NOW? UH, THE, THE RESTORATION OF BISCAYNE, AND RICK, I DON'T KNOW IF YOU HAVE IT UP.

SURE, IT'S UM, FOR WATERWAY AND SPOIL ISLANDS CLEANUP, WATER QUALITY RESTORATION EFFORTS, OR OTHER PROGRAMS OF WITH THE PURPOSE OF IMPROVING OR MAINTAINING THE QUALITY, HEALTH, AND SAFETY OF THE CITY'S WATERWAYS. SO IT'S, IT'S AIRTIGHT.

IT'S EARMARKED.

EARMARKED FOR THAT.

AND THEN, UM, IF THEY, UM, IF WE SAY NO TO FUNDING THIS, ARE THEY PREPARED? HAVE THEY GIVEN ANY INDICATION THAT THEY WILL THEN PAY FOR IT THEMSELVES, OR THEY WILL HAVE NO ADDITIONAL SERVICE THAT THEY'RE ASKING FOR US TO SUBSIDIZE? THAT'S A GOOD QUESTION, COMMISSIONER. I DO NOT KNOW, UM, WE CAN ASK THEM. I KNOW THERE WAS A REPRESENTATIVE FROM INFORMA HERE EARLIER, BUT I, I, I DON'T SEE THEM HERE NOW.

UM, THAT THEY WOULD NEED TO RESPOND TO THAT.

OKAY. AND THEN I HAVE ANOTHER QUESTION. BASED ON OUR CONTRACT WITH THE WATER TAXI, UM, IF THEY WERE TO SAY, IF WE DECLINE THIS OFFER AND THEN WE JUST HAVE OUR 2 BOATS, ARE THEY ABLE TO BRING IN SOMEONE ON F- YOU KNOW, A YACHT THAT'S NOT OUR CONTRACTED PRO- PROVIDER TO SUBSIDIZE THEIR WATERWAYS, OR DO THEY HAVE TO GO WITH OUR CONTRACTED? NO, THEY DON'T HAVE TO GO WITH OURS.

OKAY.

AS A MATTER OF FACT, UH, FOR THE FORT LAUDERDALE BOAT SHOW, THEY USE, UM, THEY USE THEIR VENDOR THAT THEY PROCURE.

HAPPENS TO BE THE SAME VENDOR WE CURRENTLY HAVE HERE FOR OUR WATER TAXI SERVICES, BUT IT'S, IT'S AN ENGAGEMENT THAT THEY, YOU KNOW, THEY, THEY, UH, TAKE THE LEAD ON, AND THEY'RE RESPONSIBLE FOR.

THEY DON'T HAVE TO GO WITH OUR VENDOR.

OKAY, THANK YOU.

HOW WAS THE UTILIZATION? I KNOW THAT THE FERRY BACK AND FORTH BETWEEN THE MAINLAND WAS VERY HEAVILY UTILIZED. UM, AM I RIGHT IN THINKING, JOSE, IS THIS TO INCREASE THE AMOUNT AND FREQUENCY OF THAT, OR IS THIS MORE FOR GETTING FROM ANOTHER AREA TO THE MARINA THAT'S SET UP IN INDIAN CREEK? SO IT WOULD BE THE, THE SAME SERVICE ACROSS BISCAYNE BAY THAT WE'RE CURRENTLY PROVIDING, UH, MONDAY THROUGH FRIDAYS. SO FROM THE VENETIAN MARINA AT THE CITY OF MIAMI IN DOWNTOWN MIAMI YEAH.

TO MARISCA MEMORIAL PARK. IT WOULD BE THAT SERVICE.

SO DID WE DO ANY TYPE OF FURRY SERVICE TO THE INDIAN CREEK, UM, PROJECT SPOT? NOT CURRENTLY, NOR WOULD BOAT SHOW UNDER THIS PROPOSAL.

YEAH, OKAY.

THEY WOULD COMPLEMENT THE WATER TAXI SERVICE WITH SHUTTLES TO, TO, UH, TO, TO, YOU KNOW, TO THE CONVENTION CENTER.

BUT THAT PART IS NOT CHANGING.

THAT, THAT'S ALL PART OF THEIR, THAT'S ALL PART OF THEIR TRANSPORTATION PLAN.

HOWEVER, THAT COMPONENT OF IT, THEY SAID THAT THEY WOULD, UH, FUND.

OKAY, SO. THE SHUTTLES.

THAT PART I, I, I DID MISUNDERSTAND.

SO THIS IS JUST ABOUT ENHANCING THE SERVICE BACK AND FORTH ON BISCAYNE BAY BETWEEN THE MAINLAND. YES.

UM, SO THEN, SO LAST YEAR, DID WE HAVE ENHANCED SHUTTLE BOAT WATER TAXI SERVICE THIS ROUTE? WAS THERE ANY TYPE OF ENHANCEMENT LAST YEAR THAT EITHER THEY PAID FOR OR WE PAID FOR? JUST OUR, WELL, WE DIDN'T EVEN HAVE OUR WATER TAXI SERVICE.

SO LAST YEAR WE HAD ABSOLUTELY NO WATER TAXI SERVICE. WE HAD NOT INITIATED, UM, YOU KNOW, THE CITY'S SERVICE YET, AND THE BOAT SHOW DID NOT PROVIDE WATER TAXI SERVICE. IN LIEU OF THAT, THEY PROVIDED SHUTTLE SERVICES.

RIGHT. AND THEY'RE GOING TO PROVIDE THAT SAME SHUTTLE SERVICE. HAVE THEY MENTIONED THAT THEY'RE GOING TO PROVIDE THAT SAME SHUTTLE SERVICE THAT THEY DID LAST YEAR? YES.

OKAY.

YES.

SO ALL THEY'RE ASKING FOR US IS, FOR US, SO THEY'RE PROVIDING EXACTLY WHAT THEY PROVIDED LAST YEAR, BUT THEY'RE ASKING US FOR AN ENHANCEMENT.

MM-HMM.

YEAH, FOR THE WATER TAXI SERVICE, YES, AND JUST FOR THE RECORD, THEY ARE PROPOSING 2 ADDITIONAL SHUTTLE ROUTES FOR 2027 AS COMPARED TO TO 2026.

OKAY.

OKAY.

BUT BUT BUT THOSE 2, THOSE 2 ADDITIONAL SHUTTLE ROUTES ARE IN CONNECTION WITH THE WATER TAXI SERVICE.

OKAY.

IT'S THE WATER TAXI CONNECTOR.

BECAUSE WE DIDN'T HAVE WATER TAXI LAST YEAR.

RIGHT. IT'S THE WATER TAXI.

SO THEY'RE ENHANCING THEIR SHUTTLE SERVICE RIGHT.

FOR THIS YEAR. OKAY.

AND, AND IF I MAY, TO PROVIDE MORE OF A CLARITY,

[01:45:01]

THEY'VE ALWAYS HAD THE SHUTTLES AND THE FERRIES, BUT LAST YEAR THEY DIDN'T BECAUSE THEY MOVED THE YACHT SHOW ONTO MIAMI BEACH. BUT I FEEL FROM CONVERSATIONS, THEY PROB- THEY FEEL LIKE THERE'S STILL A LOT OF CONGESTION IN THE CITY, SO ALLOWING THE FERRY AND THE SHUTTLES ELIMINATES SOME CARS MOVING IN THE CITY TO ALLEVIATE, UM.

SO THEY'RE ENHANCING THEIR SHUTTLE SERVICE FROM WHAT THEY OFFERED US LAST YEAR.

THAT'S WHAT THEY'RE PROPOSING.

BUT THEY WANT US TO ENHANCE OUR TRA- OUR WATER TAXI SERVICE.

RIGHT.

MM-HMM.

OKAY, I UNDERSTAND. THANK YOU.

UM... I'M JUST SURPRISED THAT THEY COULDN'T HELP OUT GETTING A LOGICAL SPONSOR ON THE WATERWAYS TO HELP WITH A FURRY SERVICE. I MEAN, THE CRUISE LINES WOULD COME TO MIND, YOU KNOW, FOR SOMETHING AS PROMINENT AS THE BOAT SHOW, ONE OF THE BOAT SPONSORS, THAT WOULD SEEM TO JUST FALL VERY HAND IN HAND, UH, ONE OF THE BOAT MANUFACTURERS OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT. CAN WE HAVE CITY STAFF MAYBE WORK WITH, UH, INFORMA TO SEE IF THEY CAN FIND A SPONSOR THAT WOULD ACTUALLY SPONSOR THE ENHANCED FURRY BACK AND FORTH FOR THAT WEEKEND.

UM, YOU KNOW, I, I DON'T KNOW WHAT A GOOD BOAT NAME WOULD BE, BUT, UH, NOT, NOT GOING THERE, UM, BUT GRADY WHITE, YOU KNOW, BOAT SERVICE OR WHATEVER IT MAY BE, UH, JUST SEEMS LIKE IT WOULD BE VERY LOGICAL FOR, YOU KNOW, THE BOAT SHOW.

I THINK IT'S SOMETHING THAT'S, THAT STAFF CAN, IF THE ITEM IS TO NOT MOVE FORWARD, YOU KNOW, WITH CITY FUNDING FOR THIS ENHANCED LEVEL OF WATER TAXIS AS I THINK BUT IT SEEMS LIKE WE'RE ALREADY GOING TO HAVE AN ENHANCED LEVEL IF WE, IF YOU'RE TELLING ME WE DIDN'T HAVE THE FURRY LAST YEAR.

CORRECT.

AND WE HAVE THE FURRY THIS YEAR.

SO THERE'S, THERE IS ENHANCED LEVEL IN THIS, THE CONCEPT THERE WAS NO WATER TAXI LAST YEAR, AND THAT THIS YEAR THERE WILL BE A WATER TAXI, BUT TO GO ABOVE AND BEYOND WHAT WE ALREADY HAVE FUNDED, UM, IF THE ISSUE, IT, IT SOUNDS LIKE THE COMMITTEE MAY BE KIND OF LETTING THAT LIE, AND IF THIS ITEM IS JUST GOING TO BE HEARD AND CLOSED, I THINK STAFF CAN STILL GO BACK AND SAY, LOOK, IT WAS HEARD AT COMMITTEE, THERE WASN'T AN APPETITE, BUT THEY, THEY, YOU KNOW, THEY, THEY WOULD RECOMMEND PERHAPS, AND THEY MAY, MAYBE THAT'S IN THEIR, THEIR PLAN B, IS TO PERHAPS WORK WITH SPONSORS AND THAT WE COULD HELP FACILITATE IT BEING EXECUTED, BUT AT NO COST TO THE CITY, THAT THEY WOULD HAVE A SPONSOR FULLY COVERED.

YEAH, I THINK THAT'S WHAT I, I'D LIKE THIS TO TURN INTO.

MAYBE WE COULD, UH, HAVE STAFF WORK WITH, UH, INFORMA TO SEE IF THEY CAN FIND A SPONSOR THAT WILL SPONSOR, UH, THAT'S RELATED TO THE BOAT SHOW, THAT WOULD, UM, SPONSOR THE ENHANCED, UH, WATER TAXI SERVICE FOR THAT WEEK.

I THINK, I THINK STAFF HAS HEARD THAT, AND I THINK STAFF CAN HAVE THAT CONVERSATION, BUT I DON'T THINK IT HAS TO GO COME OUT OF COMMITTEE. I- I- I THINK IT CAN, IF THAT'S THE INTENT, IS JUST TO TO BE HEARD, AND I SEE RICK I, I, I AGREE. I, I BELIEVE THAT STAFF WOULD BE HELPFUL TO INFORMA REGARDLESS OF WHAT THE COMMITTEE SAID OR DIDN'T SAY.

RIGHT. SO, I DON'T THINK THERE'S AN ISSUE.

SO IF, IF THE COMMITTEE'S FINE, WE CAN JUST SHOW THE ITEM HEARD AND CLOSED, AND BUT STAFF DID HEAR THAT THEY'RE, YOU KNOW, THE, THAT THEY COULD WORK WITH INFORMA TO SEE IF THEY CAN GET A SPONSORSHIP TO HAVE AN, AN ADDITIONAL ENHANCEMENT LEVEL. OKAY. OKAY. SO WE'LL SHOW THE ITEM HEARD AND CLOSED.

ANY OTHER ITEMS, UH, CHAIR? NO, I THINK THAT'S ALL. OKAY, SO WE'LL SHOW THE MEETING ADJOURNED. THANK YOU. SEE YOU ALL BACK IN A FEW.

* This transcript was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.